Skip to content

HSUS Sued for Defamation, Malicious Prosecution, Conspiracy, and Abuse of Process

Several years ago we wrote about the case of Denisa Malott, an Arkansas woman who had her horses seized by HSUS for allegedly not caring for them—only to find that the horses were, after the seizure, apparently dropped off in a field and left without adequate food and water, despite HSUS's promise that the animals would be taken to a care facility.

Previously, Malott had filed a complaint with the FBI asking for an investigation under the Animal Enterprise Terrorism Act. And now the other shoe has dropped: Malott has filed a lawsuit. Read it here.

The suit, filed in February in the Circuit Court of Stone County, Arkansas, seeks unspecified damages for defamation, malicious prosecution, abuse of process, intentional infliction of emotional distress, trespass to real property, trespass to chattels, and conspiracy. The defendants are the Humane Society of the United States, HSUS's state legislative director Desiree Bender, the Humane Society of Missouri, and three other individuals.

The seizure occurred in November 2009, after which Malott was charged with 25 felony counts of animal cruelty. Those charges were later dropped to misdemeanors—and then those charges were completely dropped altogether, in November 2011. In short, Malott had to sit under the looming threat of criminal prosecution for two years after the seizure that was conducted by HSUS and others.

Following the seizure, HSUS put out a press release in which HSUS state director Desiree Bender alleged the horses were living in “deplorable conditions” and HSUS claimed that the “horses are being taken to The Rescue Wranglers' pasture in White Hall, Ark., where they will receive the attention they deserve.”

But Malott alleges that the attention the horses got was far from what they deserved.

Instead of going to The Rescue Wranglers' pasture three hours away, the horses were found close to the seizure site. What's more, they allegedly were found to be without adequate food and water—essentially dropped off in a pasture, found the sound of it.

Malott wasn't allowed to feed her horses because of the pending criminal charges, but she eventually won physical custody of the animals and was able to feed them. TheJune/July 2010 edition of MareConnection has more details about the seizure and subsequent events.

In short, Malott's lawsuit asserts that the allegations of HSUS and others were false, which damaged her reputation and business. She's essentially saying: “Prove it.” So we'll see what HSUS has got to back up its actions. But if her horses were seized under false pretenses or HSUS made defamatory statements, then the organization could be pretty deep in manure.

Two other HSUS “raids” have spurred lawsuits: One in South Dakota and one in Hawaii. The South Dakota case is still active and is slowly progressing. HSUS is also facing a federal lawsuit filed under anti-racketeering statutes. As always, we'll keep an eye on this case and keep you posted as to any developments.

More Stories

  • Trainers meet prior to 2019 kickoff

    Members of the Walking Horse Trainers’ Association met for a regular pre-show meeting Wednesday March 20 at the Blue Ribbon Circle, on the grounds of the Celebration, which means one thing — the 2019 show season is about to heat up. Read More
  • Obituary — Mina Seaton

    Mina Seaton, wife of Bud Seaton, passed away Monday, March 18, 2019 after an extended illness. Mina was 82 years old... Read More
  • Equine Obituary – Generator’s Santana

    With heavy hearts, it was reported that 1997 World Grand Champion Generator’s Santana was humanely laid to rest March 10. He was foaled Oct. 8, 1991. Santana had dealt with EPM for several years and lived and fought well. Read More
  • Oldies but Goodies: Many walking horses stand the test of time in the show ring

    One of the most special aspects of the Tennessee Walking Horse is the longevity they demonstrate when it comes to their show ring careers. While in many breeds it’s not unusual for a horse to retire in his mid-teen years, the walking horse is known for standing the test of time. It’s not uncommon to hear of one competing at age 20. Read More
  • Latest Issue WHYIR 18

    Read More
  • National Trainers' Show Live Stream

    What A Horse will be handling the Live Streaming duties for the National Trainers' Show again this year. ReporTV will be posting highlight videos the following day of each session. Results and judges' cards for the show will be also be Live, so tune in at 6:00 pm each night.  Read More
  • Latest Issue 3 18 19

    Read More
  • Trainers’ Show announces giveaway prizes

    The WHTA 51st Annual National Trainers’ Show announced that they were giving “Giveaway Prizes” throughout the show and there will be two grand prizes given away on Saturday night.  Read More
  • WHOA Schooling/Academy Show updates class schedule

    The Walking Horse Owners Association would like to announce this weekend Schooling/Academy show starts at 12 noon at Pleasant Valley Farm in Shelbyville, TN. Extra classes have been added for Lead Line and the Yearling Division: Yearling Fillies/Geldings, Yearling Amateur and Yearling Colts. Read More
  • New entry format at Trainers’ Show

    The 51st annual Trainers’ Show will offer a new entry format that is quick, simple and easy to use. Dee Cantrell suggests exhibitors and trainers go to where directions will readily walk anyone through the entry process... Read More