Skip to content

FAST issues update

Following the 2016 Celebration, APHIS filed 188 cases against participants whose horses VMO’s had failed during inspections at the Celebration. This extraordinary action called for the industry to seek a legal response from challenging these administrative proceedings. The Celebration, SHOW Inc., FAST and several individual contributors, requested the attorneys who had filed successful lawsuits in Contender I and II to assist in examining a strategy to challenge what the industry considered a disproportionate attack on the industry. After fully considering multiple approaches, it was decided to challenge the legal authority of the USDA’s ALJs (Administrative Law Judges) and Judicial Officers to adjudicate HPA cases. 

Initially, the attorney filed a brief in the District of Columbia Court of Appeals supporting a challenge to the authority of the SEC’s administrative law judges. That case, Lucia v. SEC, claimed SEC ALJs were not appointed as required by the U.S. Constitution, and pointed out to the court that this was also the case with USDA ALJs. Ultimately, the court split five to five in that case resulting in a decision rejecting our position.

The Lucia decision was then appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, which agreed to hear and decide the issue. Our attorney filed a comprehensive brief contending that ALJs are not lawfully appointed. While the case was pending, the USDA suspended all activity in the many pending HPA cases to await the Court’s decision. On June 21, 2018, the Supreme Court decided that the SEC’s ALJs functioned as inferior officers of the United States who had not been constitutionally appointed. 

Our attorney is also assisting in five appeals cases involving HPA decisions by an ALJ and the Judicial Officer whereby the standing of the cases is suitable to challenge the constitutionality of ALJs and JO’s deciding HPA cases.  Therefore, the D.C. Circuit will have to decide in the near future whether USDA ALJs are lawfully appointed. The court will be bound by the Supreme Court’s decision in Lucia. There are other issues in those cases, including whether USDA ALJs and the Judicial Officer violated due process in their decisions, whether §1825(c) disqualification penalties can be assessed in a proceeding where the respondent has not previously been found to have violated the HPA, and whether the Judicial Officer is unconstitutionally appointed. 
The effort in supporting the Lucia petitioner in the D.C. Circuit and Supreme Court has been successful and should serve as a catalyst to require significant changes in adjudicative proceedings seeking to enforce the HPA. We will work to make sure these changes are ones that lead to fair proceedings conducted in accordance with law. 

In addition to this important initiative, FAST has revived its horse show development program and has begun accepting grant applications via its website to support new shows or revive ones that have been lost in the past several years.  

FAST has also recently announced funding availability to an organization who wishes to hold a Tennessee Walking Horse Educational event for youth.  Requests for funding may also be applied for via the FAST website.

Lastly, FAST will again hold its 50-50 fundraiser at the Celebration to raise funds to support educational and marketing initiatives for the TWH industry.  

FAST remains committed to preserving, protecting and advancing all disciplines of the Tennessee Walking Horse and extends its gratitude and appreciation to all of those industry supporters who have donated time and resources to advancing our mission!

Dr. Kasey C. Kesselring, President

More Stories

  • **Updated Horse Show Schedule

    The Walking Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse shows... Read More
  • 42nd WHOA International Face Masks

    Previously, WHOA announced protocols for the wearing of face masks during the International. Masks are required per county, and MTSU regulations. Wearing a mask in the show ring is not required while mounted, and handlers of Weanlings, Yearlings, Model, In-Hand or, Showmanship in the show ring. Masks are required in the Warm-up arena. Read More
  • WHTA moves Trainers’ Show to October

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association has its National Trainers’ Show on the move again. In what can only be considered a crazy year, the National Trainers’ Show was supposed to be held March 19-21 at Calsonic Arena in Shelbyville. And then the coronavirus came to wreck all sports including the Trainers’ Show... Read More
  • Obituary – James Wilkerson

    James C. Wilkerson, age 79 of Maryville, passed away Saturday, August 8, 2020. James was the owner and president of Serviceway Motor Freight Inc. for over 35 years. He was a member of the Jaycee’s and the Knoxville Motor Transport Association... Read More
  • Grace Baptist Church to conduct Celebration Worship Service

    The Celebration recently was contacted by Jeffrey McGee of Grace Baptist Church regarding the opportunity to continue the tradition of the Celebration worship service on Sunday morning of The Celebration. The opportunity became available after Pastor Steve Murphree decided not to conduct the service this year. Read More
  • North Carolina Championship canceled

    Due to Covid-19 restrictions, the North Carolina Championship Horse Show, scheduled for October 8-10, has been canceled for this year. The North Carolina Walking Horse Association is already beginning their planning for a better experience in 2021... Read More
  • Live from International Grand Championship

    ReporTV will provide live streaming coverage from the 42nd annual International Pleasure and Colt Grand Championship, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, beginning at 4:00 pm each evening... Read More
  • Message from the President of the Alabama Walking Horse Ladies Auxiliary

    I hope everyone is planning to attend the 9th Annual AWHLA Horse Show. From the sound of things, it looks like we are going to have a great show... Read More
  • Celebration implementing Covid-19 protocols

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration continues to make preparations for the upcoming 82nd Annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration. The show will be held August 26 – September 5, 2020... Read More
  • Stake class splits announced by Celebration

    The 2020 Tennessee Walking Horse World Grand Champion will come from one of 14 horses that entered into the two qualifying classes that will be held Saturday evening August 29, 2020. The Celebration recently announced a 10% increase in entries for the 82nd Annual Celebration to be held August 26th – September 5th... Read More