Skip to content

How Much Animal Cruelty Does HSUS Defend



Reprinted from Humanewatch.org

Our education campaign telling the public that the Humane Society of the United States only gives 1% of its budget to pet shelters is truly a David-and-Goliath affair. HSUS has about 50 times our budget. But despite this, we've had success over the last four years in garnering half a million Facebook followers and spreading the word across the country.

But when you're effective, and your opponent has a lot of money and a cynical attitude—this is a group that raises $100 million a year from donors who are in the dark, after all—the response from HSUS has been to smear us and, frankly, spread false information. This has not only occurred on its CEO's blog and Facebook page, but there are surrogate groups—who either have a lot of spare time on their hands or are getting paid for their help—that parrot HSUS's misinformation and takes it to even more libelous extremes.

The biggest problem with discussing animal issues is that it's almost impossible to have rational debate. Take the issue of pregnant pig housing. Veterinarians endorse the common form of housing called individual maternity pens. HSUS doesn't like this system because it restricts movement, but it does allow for individual care and feeding, protects the animals, and meets the animals' needs.

HSUS claims that this is a “cruel” form of housing. Therefore, by taking the pro-veterinarian position that we have, HSUS can say we “defend animal cruelty”—even though that's far from the truth. If HSUS is the only arbiter of what's “cruel,” it can say whatever it likes.

See how this smear works? Well, it actually cuts both ways.

By its own logic, HSUS is advocating animal cruelty. You see, when sows are moved into group housing, they fight for dominance and animals can suffer significant injuries. (It's the “nature of the beast,” so to speak.) If we wanted to borrow HSUS's level of discourse, we could start running TV ads of lacerated, screaming pigs and say that HSUS supports animal cruelty.

But that's not all. Along with trying to silence debate with slimy tactics, HSUS and its advocates have resorted to telling lies. Here are some you might come across on the web.
• HSUS CEO Wayne Pacelle says we're “almost certainly funded by” seal clubbers and puppy millers. No, we can say with certainty we're not, as we have told him before. Note the word choice “almost certainly.” It's weasel words. Imagine if we wrote something like “HSUS's CEO has never denied being an embezzler.” That might be technically true the way it's parsed, but it's still defamatory and sleazy—just like his comments about us. And for the record, we're open about our funding: Foundations, individuals, and food and restaurant companies.
• HSUS surrogates say we “defend” crush videos, which involve killing small animals for sexual gratification. In fact, it's the opposite. We've called people who like crush videos “perverts.” They say we defend killing contests. We never have. Shark finning? Another thing we haven't defended. They say we defend illegal fur trade and dairy cow abuse. We do not advocate illegal acts or abuse. They say we defend horse soring. Again, we do not defend this or other illegal acts.

It's preposterous. It's hard to imagine what defense they would have in a libel lawsuit. Would it be that they live in an alternate universe? It's even more bizarre considering this group of malcontented HSUS backers has already retracted false and defamatory personal attacks it made against one of our staffers.

Intellectual dishonesty is bad enough. But lying about us is another thing.

Almost no one is for animal cruelty, even if they disagree on policy. The best thing anyone--any rational reader--can do is to take a calm approach to animal issues and look at the arguments on both sides.

More Stories

  • Trainers meeting held Tuesday evening

    The annual Trainers meeting took place Tuesday evening at the Celebration’s Blue Ribbon Circle, a traditional gathering of trainers and representatives from the Celebration the eve of the show kick off. Read More
  • Title holders abound

    The 79th annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration kicked off promptly at 9 a.m. Wednesday morning with the theme of the day being three words: Many World Champions. Classes were large and many of the 10 on the agenda had multiple world and world grand champions in them. Read More
  • Celebration to enforce dress code

    In keeping with the tradition and pageantry of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration, the Celebration would like to remind all exhibitors, trainers, owners and sponsors of the dress codes in center ring.  Read More
  • Celebration balances fan supply and demand for concessions

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration is unique from most sporting venues in how concessions are handled during the event. At The Celebration, tradition has been that area civic clubs rented space on the show grounds from The Celebration and sold concessions as a fundraiser for their club and the causes they serve.   Read More
  • Latest Issue Aug 23 17

    Read More
  • Celebration Live Stream

    What A Horse will be providing the Live Stream for the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration and the TWHBEA National Futurity. Highlights will be posted the following day on ReporTV... Read More
  • Kentucky Celebration judges announced

    Judging the 2017 edition of the Kentucky Celebration will be Jamie Wiley, Kemp Martin and Randy Young. Read More
  • Meet the Celebration Judges

    The selection of judges for the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration is a process requiring layers of factors and careful planning by those behind the hiring. This year’s panel serves as a great example of what goes into that decision and why the panel is primed up with the potential to be a great one. Read More
  • USDA Rolls Out New APHIS Compliance Database and Search Tool

    The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) is pleased to announce the rollout of the refined public search tool that provides access to Animal Welfare Act compliance records... Read More
  • Marsha Prock remembers the Celebration

    The following thoughts and memories about The Celebration were submitted to Walking Horse Report by horse show enthusiast Marsha Prock... Read More