Celebration files petition for rehearing
Friday, October 7, 2022
On October 6, 2022, the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Association asked the federal court of appeals in Washington D.C. to reconsider the decision issued in July that could result in resurrecting the USDA’s 2017 Horse Protection Act regulations. The 2017 regulations purport to eliminate industry inspectors and replace them with government-picked veterinarians. The 2017 regulations also ban all pads and action devices from horse showing events involving Tennessee Walking Horses. These rules were withdrawn before publication by the Trump administration in early 2017.
Our petition argues that these rules were lawfully withdrawn. Our position, consistent with that of every presidential administration from Clinton to Trump, is that federal law demands that agency rules be published in the Federal Register before they can be considered final. Because the 2017 rules were never published, they were never finalized. The agency thus still had discretion to withdraw the rules.
In the alternative, our petition asked the court of appeals to allow the lower court to determine a remedy in the case, which would allow the lower court discretion to decide against reviving the 2017 rules. Because the USDA has already acknowledged that the 2017 rules are outdated (especially in light of a recent National Academy of Sciences report) and has developed a new proposed rule that it has sent to the OMB and is preparing to release, it would make little sense to revive the 2017 rules now. We urged the court of appeals to allow the lower court wide discretion to chart a path forward in this case.
The USDA also filed a petition essentially asking the court of appeals for the same relief we sought as an alternative—that is, allowing the lower court wide discretion on remand to decide the appropriate remedy. Unfortunately the DOJ/USDA did not argue that the Court of Appeals decision was wrong—instead, they requested only that the lower Court have wide discretion on remedy.
More Stories |
-
Read More
-
The WHOA Triple Crown Cricut will start March 30 through April 1, 2023 in Pensacola, Florida at the Escambia County Equestrian Center. The Honorable Judge Darden Gladney of Homer, Alabama will judge the show.
Read More
-
On the afternoon of Tuesday, March 21, CasMol Farms of Cookeville, TN were able to showcase the great Tennessee Walking Horse breed to one of Tennessee Tech University’s agriculture classes. The Equine Production class of the College Of Agriculture and Human Ecology met with Rod Slagle and Jordan Stacy at the Hyder-Burks facility in Cookeville, TN...
Read More
-
The 55th Annual National Trainers’ Show was held in Cooper Steel Arena March 15th through the 18th on the show grounds of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration. This marks the first Tennessee Walking Horse show in the newly title sponsored Cooper Steel Arena, replacing the old naming rights holder, Calsonic Arena.
Read More
-
The Christmas In July Horse Show, scheduled for June 27-29 at the Bedford County Ag Center in Shelbyville, Tennessee, has selected Chris Bobo, Brent Grider and Chris Zahnd to mark the cards for this year's event.
Read More
-
In a true sign of unity, various industry organizations sacrificed year-end individual revenue generating events to join together to produce one final show season event to support the industry’s efforts to raise funds to support its journey toward equitable treatment among all HPA breeds.
Read More
-
The Report has learned of the passing of long-time Walking Horse enthusiast, Brenda May.
Read More
-
Read More
-
The SHOW HIO has made several updates to its 2023 rulebook. A change previously announced was the change with how horses will be required to enter the show ring. That rule is found in both the general rulebook as well as in the judges’ section of the rulebook...
Read More
-
Susan (Sue) Jane Dean, 67, of Beechgrove TN passed away on February 9th, 2023 in her home surrounded by her family.
Read More
|