Skip to content

Celebration Requests USDA Withdraw Scar Rule Violations Since May 2009



The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration (TWHNC) has asked Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack to withdraw all alleged scar rule violations since May 2009.  This request was sent to Vilsack on March 9, 2015 by Washington law firm Kelly Drye & Warren, who successfully represented the Ringling Brothers Circus against the Humane Society of the United States.

In addition, the Celebration made the following requests in their March 9 letter

1. Withdraw all scar violations issued since May 2009.

 2. Command that VMOs and DQPs immediately cease and desist from applying the factors in part (a) to the scar rule when examining the posterior surface of the pasterns.

 3. Develop new scar rule training material and protocols based on accepted principles of veterinary science that address the proper posterior surface tissue changes that the scar rule permits and does not permit.

4. Begin using those new scar rule materials only after those protocols have been reviewed and approved by the USDA, industry leaders and independent veterinarians.

 5. Require VMOs and DQPs to adhere to requirements of new training materials and inspection protocols or face dismissal.

 6. Refrain from establishing any different or additional inspection protocols regarding posterior scars until the above noted training material and inspection protocols have been put in place.

The Celebration’s request regarding the scar rule is predicated on the fact that United States Department of Agriculture (USDA Veterinary Medical Officers (VMO) have been misapplying the Horse Protection Act (HPA) specifically as it relates to alleged scar rule violations.  According to the law, USDA VMOs must attempt to flatten or smooth out the tissue in the pastern area to determine if it is uniformly thickened. 

The scar rule expressly provides that “uniformly thickened epithelial tissue” does not constitute a violation.  The scar rule acknowledges and allows tissue changes not unlike a callous on a person’s hand. USDA Head VMO Jeff Baker has been training VMOs and DQPs that it is not necessary to attempt to flatten the tissue to determine if a violation exists.   Additionally Dr. Baker has admitted neither he nor the other USDA inspectors were conducting inspections using the prescribed methodology thereby improperly alleging HPA scar rule violations where.

The letter states “by applying a factor that is irrelevant under the scar rule, its VMOs have been violating the Administrative Procedures Act (APA).”  As of this date, there has been no response from Vilsack or the USDA.

More Stories

  • NCCWHS class schedule changes

    The North Carolina Championship, scheduled for Oct. 4-6, has made the following changes to their class schedule... Read More
  • Obituary – Burl Dale

    Burl Jacob Dale entered into eternal life Tuesday, September 18, after a courageous fight with heart disease. He recently celebrated his 82nd birthday... Read More
  • Columbia honors its own

    Columbia’s mayor Dean Dickey proclaimed Sept. 20 to be Gen A' Mighty Day following the horse’s recent World Grand Championship victory at the Celebration, making the horse the fifth World Grand Champion to hail from Columbia... Read More
  • Latest Issue September 24 18

    Read More
  • A Mighty Strong Finish

    Going into the coveted World Grand Championship class Saturday night, Sept. 1, the field was somewhat wide-open for contenders riding for the biggest prize of the show. The preliminaries had given several horses a chance to shine, a few surprises emerged, and the judges were spread out with their opinions throughout the week, as was the crowd, demonstrating stiff competition. Read More
  • Oxford, NC show rescheduled

    North Carolina's PPWHANC Show scheduled for Oxford,N.C. on September 15th has been rescheduled; the new show date is September 29th with the same class schedule as previously presented.  Read More
  • #900 never to return to Celebration competition

    At the 79th anniversary of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration, Bill Callaway and Gen’s Black Maverick rode into the ring on the last Saturday night to a roar of applause and cheering, and they exited the ring in the same fashion as they claimed the title of 2017 Tennessee Walking Horse World Grand Champion... Read More
  • Obituary – Pat Kirk

    Pat Kirk, 89, of Purdy, Missouri entered into eternal rest on Tuesday September 11, 2018 while at Cox South Hospital in Springfield, Missouri.  Read More
  • Obituary - Burl Dale

    The Report has recently learned of the sudden passing of Burl Dale on September 18, 2018. A Memorial Service will be held on Saturday, September 22 at 2:00 PM at Camp Yonahnoka in Linville, North Carolina. Read More
  • Allen honored with Evan Lloyd Adamson Humanitarian Award

    The Celebration and the Adamson family are proud to announce the 2018 winner of the Evan Lloyd Adamson award, Connie Allen, director of office operations for The Celebration. Read More