Skip to content

Contender Farms, McGartland’s and SHOW File Second Suit Against USDA

On February 29, 2016, Contender Farms, L.L.P., Lee and Mike McGartland and SHOW, Inc. filed a complaint in the Fort Worth division of the United States District Court regarding the illegal enforcement schemes utilized by the USDA that are not authorized under the Horse Protection Act.  The HPA states the following:

While horses are disqualified from events based solely on the opinion of an authorized inspector, when a civil penalty may be assessed against an owner, trainer or entrant, HPA §1825(b) prescribes that “no penalty shall be assessed unless such person is given notice and opportunity for a hearing before the Secretary with respect to such violation.”

The USDA has instituted two enforcement schemes, the “Protocol for Foreign Substance Penalty,” and the “IES Investigative and Enforcement Process,” under which the USDA decides entrants are in violation of the HPA.  The suit filed by the plaintiffs claim both enforcement schemes are illegal and not authorized by the HPA.  In addition, the suit challenges the USDA’s use of information from private inspectors’ activities, which the USDA uses to falsely identify people as having been determined to have violated the HPA.

The language in the complaint specifically states:

“Plaintiffs challenge the USDA’s use of three enforcement mechanisms that are not authorized under the HPA, and which directly contravene the requirement in §1825(b) that only the Secretary, after notice and hearing can penalize a person for a violation.  Plaintiffs challend the USDA’s use of two unauthorized and unlawful administrative enforcement schemes: the “Protocol for Foreign Substance Penalty,” and the “IES Investigative and Enforcement Process,” under which the USDA decides that entrants, trainers and owners have violated the Act’s prohibition against entering sore horses. T1:1;T2:2.  Plaintiffs also challenge the USDA’s use of private party information about private inspectors’ activities, which the USDA uses to falsely identify people as having been determined to have violated the Act.  Since none of these enforcement schemes is authorized by a Department regulation or by the HPA, this suit does not involve a challenge to any provision of the HPA or USDA regulation.”

If Contender Farms, McGartland’s and SHOW prevail the USDA will be required to remove the thousands of names they have published as violators of the HPA on the APHIS web site in error.  Organizations such as the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) and Friends of Sound Horses (FOSH) utilize these lists to further their fundraising and lobbying initiatives and claim, in error, that these names represent violations of the HPA.

Prior to the filing of this second lawsuit, Judge Means ruled in favor of these same plaintiffs against the USDA in their request for reimbursement of fees.  Judge Means awarded the plaintiffs over $267,000, which the USDA will be required to pay.

Click Here to view the complaint filed.

More Stories

  • Buddy Dick passes away

    The Report has recently learned of the passing of walking horse trainer, Buddy Dick. Our thoughts and prayers go out to the entire Dick and Finish Line Farms family during this time. A full obituary will be posted as soon as it becomes available.  Read More
  • Disposition and versatility on display

    Four winners from the second annual Take A Ride on multi-World Champion Line Item Veto Facebook contest traveled to Midland Equestrian Center for an enjoyable visit and rides on Veto... Read More
  • Thomas earns Pleasure Horse Trainer of the Year award

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association Board of Directors decided to add a well-overdue and deserved category to their list of awards last year. The Pleasure Horse Trainer of the Year is voted on by their peers and must demonstrate positive attitude, dedication, motivation, is a team player, and an ambassador to their breed. Read More
  • Deadline for Fall Stallion Issue

    The annual Walking Horse Report World Champion Sire Summary and Fall Stallion issue will be the October 2, 2017 issue. The advertising deadline for the issue will be Wednesday, September 27, 2017 and the issue will mail on Friday, September 29, 2017. Read More
  • Obituary - Howard Creed

    Howard C. Creed, 83, of Springfield, Missouri, passed away September 19, 2017. He was born July 29, 1934, in Springfield, Missouri, and graduated Sr. High School in 1952. He served in the Army where he learned his lifetime trade of horse shoeing, which he did for 57 years... Read More
  • Maverick fights his way to the top

    He’s had a solid, steadily upward moving career that’s landed him so close more than once. Finally, the nine-year-old stallion — with the help of his tenacious owners, a dedicated trainer, and a supporting staff of many — earned the roses. Read More
  • Obituary - James Robert "Bob" Nelms

    Mr. James Robert “Bob” Nelms, age 67, of College Grove, Tennessee, died Monday, September 18, 2017 at his home in College Grove.  Read More
  • Honors loves all

    A huge crowd met Honors and Larry Edwards at the Celebration Saturday evening, Sept. 2, 2017, at the meet and greet for 2016 WGC Honors in front of the Blue Ribbon Club on the final night of the Celebration. Read More
  • WGC A Gin To Win visits TN State Fair

    Friday, September 15th, Abernathy Stables traveled to the Tennessee State Fair to exhibit current Three-Year-Old World Grand Champion, A Gin To Win. The Tennessee State Fair has been going on for more than 150 years and this year the Fair’s theme is “Tennessee Proud.” Read More
  • Celebration announces host hotel for Tunica Fall Classic

    The Celebration is pleased to announce that they have selected The Gold Strike Resort and Casino to again serve as host hotel for the Tunica Fall Classic, scheduled for November 2-4, 2017.  Read More