Skip to content

Contender Farms, McGartland’s and SHOW File Second Suit Against USDA

On February 29, 2016, Contender Farms, L.L.P., Lee and Mike McGartland and SHOW, Inc. filed a complaint in the Fort Worth division of the United States District Court regarding the illegal enforcement schemes utilized by the USDA that are not authorized under the Horse Protection Act.  The HPA states the following:

While horses are disqualified from events based solely on the opinion of an authorized inspector, when a civil penalty may be assessed against an owner, trainer or entrant, HPA §1825(b) prescribes that “no penalty shall be assessed unless such person is given notice and opportunity for a hearing before the Secretary with respect to such violation.”

The USDA has instituted two enforcement schemes, the “Protocol for Foreign Substance Penalty,” and the “IES Investigative and Enforcement Process,” under which the USDA decides entrants are in violation of the HPA.  The suit filed by the plaintiffs claim both enforcement schemes are illegal and not authorized by the HPA.  In addition, the suit challenges the USDA’s use of information from private inspectors’ activities, which the USDA uses to falsely identify people as having been determined to have violated the HPA.

The language in the complaint specifically states:

“Plaintiffs challenge the USDA’s use of three enforcement mechanisms that are not authorized under the HPA, and which directly contravene the requirement in §1825(b) that only the Secretary, after notice and hearing can penalize a person for a violation.  Plaintiffs challend the USDA’s use of two unauthorized and unlawful administrative enforcement schemes: the “Protocol for Foreign Substance Penalty,” and the “IES Investigative and Enforcement Process,” under which the USDA decides that entrants, trainers and owners have violated the Act’s prohibition against entering sore horses. T1:1;T2:2.  Plaintiffs also challenge the USDA’s use of private party information about private inspectors’ activities, which the USDA uses to falsely identify people as having been determined to have violated the Act.  Since none of these enforcement schemes is authorized by a Department regulation or by the HPA, this suit does not involve a challenge to any provision of the HPA or USDA regulation.”

If Contender Farms, McGartland’s and SHOW prevail the USDA will be required to remove the thousands of names they have published as violators of the HPA on the APHIS web site in error.  Organizations such as the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) and Friends of Sound Horses (FOSH) utilize these lists to further their fundraising and lobbying initiatives and claim, in error, that these names represent violations of the HPA.

Prior to the filing of this second lawsuit, Judge Means ruled in favor of these same plaintiffs against the USDA in their request for reimbursement of fees.  Judge Means awarded the plaintiffs over $267,000, which the USDA will be required to pay.

Click Here to view the complaint filed.

More Stories

  • Faces return after long absences

    This past show season saw the return of several new faces to the Tennessee Walking Horse industry — although, technically, they aren’t actually new. A few weeks back, the WHR reached out to horse enthusiasts via social media to hear the stories of any newcomers who decided to jump back in the saddle after a 10 or more-year absence... Read More
  • Latest Issue Dec 18 17

    Read More
  • Equine Obituary - The Land Shark

    World grand champion and multi world champion The Land Shark passed away on December 6, 2017. The five-year-old stallion was owned and loved by Larry and Pam Russell of Pontotoc, Mississippi... Read More
  • Walking For The Angels and WHTA give back

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association teamed up once again with Walking For The Angels and Christmas In July Horse Show to give back to those in need at Christmas time. Over 300 children across Bedford County received help this year... Read More
  • KWHA Ladies Auxiliary celebrate a great year

    The KWHA Ladies Auxiliary Christmas Luncheon was held on December 9, 2017. The event was held at Malone’s Event’s and Catering in Lexington, Kentucky. 18 members joined to celebrate a wonderful year in the horse industry and participation awards and ended the day with a dirt Santa gift exchange... Read More
  • Office Holiday Hours

    The office will be closed for Christmas holidays beginning Monday, Dec. 18, 2017, and will reopen Tuesday, Jan. 2, 2018. We hope you enjoy that time with your families as we will be... Read More
  • Walking For Cancer show announces date

    The 2018 Walking For Cancer show will be held April 21 at the Champions Arena in Shelbyville. The start time is still pending however organizers are aiming for 5 p.m. Further details will be announced as they become available... Read More
  • Youth Council awards

    New this year for the Youth Council, a point system was put into place to help encourage all youth members to participate in different events and horse shows. Throughout the year members earned points by helping to raise money for the FAST Legal Fund and for assisting at horse shows... Read More
  • Two new faces join TWHBEA Executive Committee

    The Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders’ and Exhibitors’ Association’s annual meetings were held last weekend in Lewisburg, Tennessee with two new faces joining the Executive Committee (EC) following the annual elections, held Saturday... Read More
  • Birth Announcement - Knox Lucas Robbins

    Paul and Jennifer Robbins welcomed their second son, Knox Lucas Robbins, on December 4, 2017. He weighed 8lbs., 6.5 oz and measured 20 inches in length. Read More