Skip to content

Contender Farms and SHOW Seek Recovery of Fees From USDA



The Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA) authorizes district courts to award reasonable attorneys’ fees and expenses to a prevailing party in a lawsuit against a government agency.  Contender Farms and Mike McGartland recently won an appeal in the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reversing an earlier decision by Judge Terry Means in United States District Court in July 2013 regarding the USDA’s Minimum Penalty Protocol.

In a unanimous decision in February 2015, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals Circuit found that the mandatory penalty regulation is not a valid application of USDA regulatory authority  and accordingly reversed and vacated the judgment.  As a result, in April 2015 Judge Terry Means, in accordance with the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, granted summary judgment to SHOW HIO, Contender Farms and Mike McGartland.

The application seeking the fees under EAJA must allege that the “position of the United States was not substantially justified.”  Underlying the lawsuit was one dominant legal issue; by what authority could the USDA create a liability and enforcement scheme different from the one Congress established in the HPA.  In its decision, the Fifth Circuit held that HPA §1823 and §1828 not only do not authorize the USDA to adopt the Regulation, but went further, holding that the clear language of the HPA prohibited the agency from adopting a private-party enforcement scheme different from the enforcement provisions Congress previously adopted.

The motion filed seeks recovery of fees at a minimum level of $349,749 to a maximum level of $489,500 plus expenses of $980.  SHOW HIO, Contender Farms and Mike McGartland requested the court order the government to pay the higher award in the filed motion.

Click here to view the motion filed in the United States District Court Northern District of Texas
Click here to view the brief filed supporting the application for fees
 

More Stories

  • Donations being accepted re: Peebles fire

    A fire at Dick Peebles' residence on Holt Avenue was reported shortly before noon Friday. Bedford County Fire Department reports the blaze's cause is undetermined at this time. The fire itself damaged the utility room and kitchen with smoke damage throughout the rest of the home, according to the BCSD... Read More
  • Tennessee Walking Horse museum honored for 2017 achievements

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Museum in Wartrace received two awards March 21 from the Tennessee Association of Museums. The Wartrace museum was honored with an Award of Excellence for superlative achievement for "Traveling Exhibit-Juvenile Riders" and an Award of Commendation in recognition... Read More
  • Equine Obituary - Hot Silk

    The Report has recently learned of the passing of world champion Hot Silk on April 16. Affectionately known as “Silk,” the beautiful mare was owned and loved by Lisa Teel... Read More
  • Obituary - Kenneth Joseph Wulff

    Kenneth Joseph Wulff, 66, died Thursday, April 12, 2018 at his home. Born October 2, 1951 in Jefferson City, Missouri he was the son of the late Victor J. and Coletta (Werdenhause) Wulff. Ken graduated from the University of Missouri and worked as a loan officer for Movement Mortgage locally. Read More
  • WHT Auxiliary Scholarship

    The Walking Horse Trainers' Auxiliary has released their 2018 Scholarship information. Read More
  • Obituary - Joseph Martin Finch

    Joseph Martin Finch of Shelbyville, Tennessee passed away Tuesday April 3, 2018, surrounded by his family. Joe is survived by his wife Gail, his three daughters, Kim Withrow, Suzie Finch and Lisa McMahan, his three grandchildren, Joseph, Brooks and Max Withrow and his brother Bill Finch. In lieu of a funeral service, a Celebration of Life will be held for family and friends at the Blue-Ribbon Circle Club on the Celebration Show Grounds April 22nd from 1-4pm. All friends and family are invited. Read More
  • Latest Issue April 16 18

    Read More
  • Celebration selects Fun Show judges

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration has selected its judging panel for the 48th Annual Spring Fun Show to be held in Calsonic Arena May 24-26.  The judging panel of Jamie Hankins, David Sisk and Johnny Puckett is a blend of experience with a new face to Celebration judging. Read More
  • HSUS loses charity accreditation

    The Humane Society of the United States has lost its accreditation by the charity arm of the Better Business Bureau. This action follows the resignations, earlier this year, by former CEO Wayne Pacelle and vice president Paul Shapiro... Read More
  • AL Ladies Auxiliary selects Dekle

    The Alabama Ladies Auxiliary Show, scheduled for May 5, has selected Mack Dekle of Shelbyville, Tennessee to mark the cards for this year's event. The show will be held at the Celebration Arena in Priceville, Alabama. Read More