Skip to content

Edwards HPA Trial Suspended



Editor's Note:  The following was submitted by Alie Napier, an attorney with the Norton Law Firm, who represents the Edwards.

As many of you may know, the first HPA trial involving a post-show scar rule prosecution began this past Tuesday, May 17, 2016.  For those that did not know, the allegations involved two horses, three people and one training facility.  The USDA was prosecuting Gary Edwards, Paige Edwards, and Carl Edwards and Sons Stables for a post-show scar rule violation written by Dr. Jeffery Baker at the 2010 Celebration on the horse “A Victoria Secret” following her win in the 15-17 preliminary class.  Additionally, the USDA was prosecuting Larry Edwards, Paige Edwards and Carl Edwards and Sons Stables for a post-show scar rule violation written by Dr. Jeffery Baker at the 2012 Celebration on the horse “He’s Unleashed” following his third place tie in his preliminary stake class division.

After three days of trial, the attorney for the USDA moved to suspend the trial because the government had failed to provide the Edwards’ attorneys with certain exhibits prior to the hearing commencing as required by the Rules of Practice and Procedure.  The only remedy available to the USDA to cure this mishap was to ask for a continuance so the Edwards and their attorneys would be provided ample time to review the evidence and prepare their defense.  The Court granted the continuance and the hearing will resume, presumably if the case is not settled, sometime next year.

While this is not the exact outcome those involved wanted at this time, there were definitely some positives and several legal victories for our industry that should not be overlooked.  First, about half way through the hearing on Wednesday, May 18, 2016, the USDA agreed to dismiss with prejudice Paige Edwards from both cases.  Mrs. Edwards was alleged to have signed the Celebration entry form and was being prosecuted for that reason.  After the Edwards’ attorney argued that the entry process was completed once a horse entered and finished the show, the USDA, while not agreeing to that argument on record, did agree to dismiss with prejudice Mrs. Edwards from any further prosecution in both cases.

Second, and in my opinion the biggest scar rule victory we, as an industry, have received in years, was that the Judge, Honorable Jill Clifton, went on record to say that she does not like the scar rule.  She felt it was extremely subjective and would urge all involved to find a more objective way to resolve this issue.  She even went on to opine that she believed the Edwards family has abided to the Sound Horse, Honest Judging, Objective Inspections, and Winning Fairly theories embodied by the SHOW, HIO, and that the Edwards were fighting these allegations because they truly felt the VMO was mistaken in his subjective decision to write both horses up for a scar rule violation.  Once the transcript of the hearing is received, we will hopefully be able to make her announcement on record available for the public.

Unfortunately, the legal process is an extremely slow process.  The administrative proceedings for HPA cases are even slower.  There are currently only two judges and a handful of attorneys prosecuting all USDA matters, including HPA cases.  So, while it may be some time before we get the opportunity for a specific ruling on a scar rule prosecution, I think the small victories from this week should not be overlooked.        

Alie Napier

More Stories

  • Latest Issue 3 1 31

    Read More
  • Walking In The Smokies stall deadline approaching

    The Walking In The Smokies Horse Show, scheduled for April 8-10, 2021, in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee is preparing for their first annual show and would like to send a reminder to anyone needing stalls that the deadline is March 15. Please contact Lexi Stinnett at 828-550-8520 to reserve stalls on the show grounds. Read More
  • Trainers' Show announces judges

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association National Trainers’ Show will be held at Calsonic Arena in Shelbyville, Tenn. March 18-20, 2021. Judges for the three-day event will be Wayne Dean, Newton Parks and Johnny Puckett. Read More
  • USDA prepares for 2021 show season

    The USDA recently conducted their virtual HIO training course for the 2021 show season. The USDA and industry recently received the final report from the National Academies of Sciences (NAS) and some of the recommendations in that report are communicated in the new processes the USDA will implement in 2021... Read More
  • WHOA hosts virtual awards ceremony

    On Saturday. February 20th, the Walking Horse Owners’ Association (WHOA) held their National High Point awards for 2020 on their WHOA Facebook page with winners who chose to be zooming in to accept their awards... Read More
  • WHOA to host virtual awards ceremony on February 20

    The Walking Horse Owners’ Association (WHOA) will recognize their award winners from the 2020 show season during a virtual awards ceremony on Saturday, February 20, 2021. The show will be broadcast live on WHOA’s Facebook page beginning at 6 pm central time. Read More
  • FAST Spring Showcase announces judging panel

    The FAST Spring Showcase is pleased to announce that John Fikes, Newton Parks and Sam Sorrell will judge this years’ two-day event. The show will be held at Calsonic Arena in Shelbyville, Tenn. April 16-17, 2021... Read More
  • Obituary – Kimberly Woods

    Kimberly Lynn Woods, age 47 departed this life on Sunday, February 14, 2021 at the University of Kentucky Medical Center in Lexington, Kentucky... Read More
  • WHAA annual barn party rescheduled due to inclement weather

    There will be a lot of great items to auction as well as breeding fees to some of the top stallions in the industry and training fees for many of the top trainers. Everyone is encouraged to bring your young horses to preview for the upcoming show season. Read More
  • Birth Announcement – William Jackson Bauer

    Dr. & Mrs. Will  Bauer of Gainesville, Georgia welcomed their first child, William Jackson Bauer, on December 4, 2020. Jack weighed 7 pounds, 2 ounces at birth... Read More