HSUS continues to push for implementation of 2017 HPA rule
Tuesday, January 24, 2023
The Humane Society of the United States continues to push the DC circuit to force the USDA to implement the 2017 Horse Protection Act rule that would devastate the current show horse. The DC Circuit Court of Appeals recently rejected the USDA’s appeal of their earlier decision and denied the intervention request of The Celebration.
The DC Court of Appeals remanded the case back to the district court to consider the remedy in the case. HSUS insists in its initial briefs that the only solution is to vacate the withdrawal of the rule and implement the rule immediately. The USDA will file response briefs in the coming weeks and will argue against vacating of the rule as they have stated they have a new rule coming out and don’t want to implement the old rule.
The USDA has been on record not wanting to implement the old rule due to several problems in the rule. “We withdrew that rule because the data that supported it was outdated, and we wanted to use new data plus the National Academies report to come out with a more solid rule. There are people opposed to what we do in horse protection, and they’re not shy about suing us. So when we put a regulation in place, we want it to be as airtight as possible. To have just used the old rule, I think, would’ve made us vulnerable for a legal attack. We want to put out an up-to-date rule based on good data, and it’s our intention and Secretary Vilsack’s intention to do that. We hope to do it, certainly, by the end of this calendar year (2022). And, of course, we’re always hoping Congress might act, too.”
The Celebration is also seeking intervention before the DC circuit in this phase of the case as well and will be submitting briefs arguing against the need to vacate the six-year-old rule’s withdrawal. The briefing in the case should be complete by mid-March with a decision from the court following. The exact timing of that decision is not known and will be impacted by the amount of caseload in front of the judge.
In remanding the case back to the district court, the Court of Appeals recommended to the lower court to consider alternate remedies to vacating of the withdrawal. Depending on the decision of the judge, USDA and potentially the industry will have several different courses of action to consider.
The industry commented on the rule back in 2017 and fiercely opposed many of the stipulations in that rule, including the elimination of the pad, action device, band and weighted shoe as well as the abolishment of the Horse Industry Organization system and a total reliance on the federal government for enforcement of the HPA. It is safe to assume the industry would immediately seek a stay on the implementation of the rule and file litigation challenging the validity of the rule.
The old rule does not take into consideration any data or recommendations from the National Academies of Science review of the inspection process, which was jointly funded by the industry, USDA and State of Tennessee. The USDA has publicly stated that the new rule will take into account this study as well as many other updates to the old rule. The old rule is reliant on data that is up to 10-15 years old and doesn’t consider more current inspection data from the industry and USDA which is dramatically different.
More Stories |
-
The Report has learned of the passing of Merle Stuart. Mr. Stuart was a long-time supporter of the Tennessee walking horse and father of Leigh Stuart, Lynn Marchetti and Jim Stuart and the husband of Shirley Stuart.
Read More
-
The Walking Horse Owners Association would like to remind you that tomorrow, Wednesday, February 1, is the deadline for making reservations for the WHOA High Points Awards. All WHOA members are invited to attend the annual membership meeting and Banquet.
Read More
-
Congratulations to the following individuals whom were reelected to the North Carolina Walking Horse Association Board of Directors...
Read More
-
The March 1st deadline to pay WHTA Auxiliary dues to be eligible to show in WHTA Auxiliary classes is quickly approaching. Dues are $30 per year, unless you are a past president...
Read More
-
FAST is happy to announce that Derek Bonner, Wayne Dean and Jamie Lawrence will judge the FAST Spring Showcase on April 14-15, 2023. The show will be held in the Cooper Steel Arena (formerly Calsonic Arena) on the Celebration Grounds in Shelbyville, Tennessee.
Read More
-
Read More
-
The Humane Society of the United States continues to push the DC circuit to force the USDA to implement the 2017 Horse Protection Act rule that would devastate the current show horse. The DC Circuit Court of Appeals recently rejected the USDA’s appeal of their earlier decision and denied the intervention request of The Celebration.
Read More
-
Mr. Sammy Cagle age 74 of Lexington, TN. passed away on Saturday January 21, 2023 at Jackson Madison County Hospital in Jackson, TN...
Read More
-
The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration announced at its annual meeting that Calsonic Arena will have a new title sponsor and unveiled the naming of Cooper Steel Arena. The partnership will be the most significant outside investment in The Celebration’s history and will lock up the naming rights for at least the next 20 years.
Read More
-
The Walking Horse Owners’ Association is proud to announce the following candidates were elected to the WHOA Board of Directors by the WHOA Membership...
Read More
|