Skip to content

HSUS Lobbyist Subject in Ethical Investigation



reposted from HumaneWatch.org

An independent investigation into Kentucky Representative Ed Whitfield found there is “substantial reason to believe” that the legislator unethically facilitated the lobbying efforts of his wife, who is a registered lobbyist for the legislative arm of the Humane Society of the United States.

The House rules prohibit this brand of spousal scheming, explicitly forbidding lawmakers’ staff “from making any lobbying contact…with that individual’s spouse if that spouse is a lobbyist…for the purpose of influencing legislation.” But accusations against Rep. Whitfield contend that the Congressman and his wife violated these guidelines.

According to a report by the Board of the Office of Congressional Ethics (OCE), Connie Harriman-Whitfield allegedly contacted her husband’s congressional staff “on numerous occasions,” scheduling “as many as 100 meetings with other congressional offices” through his staff. The 26-page OCE report quotes email exchanges in which Harriman-Whitfield appears to use her unique access for calculated professional gain. In one such email, for example, Harriman-Whitfield details the legislative advantages of her marital situation: “Neither HSUS or HSLF [the legislative arm of HSUS] will be able to do well setting up meetings with Republican offices…That is why Ed’s office was so crucial in setting up meetings between Republicans and third parties.” According to the Board Report, this use of “Ed’s office” was particularly important in gaining Republican support for HSUS-backed anti-horse soring legislation—a bill sponsored, incidentally, by Rep. Whitfield.

Other emails appear to also implicate HSUS leadership as complicit cohorts in Harriman-Whitfield’s allegedly unethical lobbying activity. In one message, for instance, the HSUS Federal Affairs Director requests that Harriman-Whitfield ask her husband to co-sponsor a bill supported by HSUS. This email suggests that HSUS actively participated in the alleged unethical lobbying—a degree of involvement reinforced by another email in which HSUS Vice President contacts the scheduler directly to arrange a series of legislative meetings.

The Board elaborates: “Although [Rep. Whitfield’s] Scheduler told the OCE that she arranged the meetings at the request of Representative Whitfield, emails from HSUS Vice President and Representative Whitfield’s Wife indicate that many meetings were scheduled at the request of HSUS.”

Despite this alleged involvement—or perhaps because of it— HSUS President Wayne “I don’t love animals” Pacelle issued a public statement defending Rep. Whitfield and challenging the motives of his complainants. Pacelle insists: “[G]roups who brought the Ethics Committee complaint are engaged in torturing horses, and have tried to place obstacles in the way of passing the legislation.”

But other evidence suggests that opponents of Whitfield’s horse legislation aren’t the only ones with reason to be concerned about the alleged activity. In an email to the Congressman, Rep. Whitfield’s Chief of Staff explained that the conduct of Rep. Whitfield and his wife was raising red flags on Capitol Hill. The Chief reported having a “very uncomfortable conversation” with another lawmaker’s office over the “optics” of arranging meetings for a registered lobbyist.

Ultimately, regardless of who issued the complaint—or why they chose to do so—this hectoring is just Pacelle trying to change the subject. Unethical activity would be unethical activity regardless of the complainant. The OCE investigation concluded that the evidence of unethical lobbying activity is persuasive enough to warrant an extended review. The Board was unanimous: All six members recommended that the OCE continue its evaluation of the allegations.

More Stories

  • Latest Issue 5 27 19

    Read More
  • Trainers gather for pre-Fun Show meeting

    A light crowd of about 20 gathered for the annual pre-show meeting among members of the Walking Horse Trainers’ Association at 4 p.m. Wednesday at the Blue Ribbon Circle on the Celebration grounds. The meeting served as the official opener of weekend events in conjunction of the Spring Fun Show.  Read More
  • LIVE from Spring Fun Show

    The Report will be providing LIVE coverage from all three nights from the Spring Fun Show on ReporTV this weekend. Highlights from the show will be posted the following day. There will also be LIVE results and judges' cards. Read More
  • EP outbreak doesn’t include TWHs

    A recent outbreak in Equine Piroplasmosis (EP) in Middle Tennessee has not been reported to include walking horses, although horses located in Bedford County are among the 22 horses that have tested positive for the blood parasite... Read More
  • Bedford County To Get New Upscale Community Designed For Adults 55 and Up

    H Global Investments and American Home Inc., announce plans to develop new community geared toward adults desiring luxury living with an eye toward their retirement years. Fieldstone will be situated on property located along Highway 231 North and Midland Road... Read More
  • FAST awards grant to Arab Football Booster Club Summer Classic

    FAST is pleased to announce that they are awarding a $1500.00 Grant to The Arab Football Booster Club Summer Classic. This show will be June 15, 2019, and is put on by The Walking Horse Association of Alabama. The FAST Board voted unanimously to approve this grant request. Read More
  • Palmetto Saddle Club Show rescheduled

    The Palmetto Saddle Club Horse Show, originally scheduled for May 18, has been rescheduled for November 2, 2019. Read More
  • WHOA Spring Classic at Harlinsdale Farm

    The Walking Horse Owners Association Spring Classic will be held this Saturday, May 18, 2019 at 10 am at The Park at Harlinsdale Farm in Franklin, Tennessee. This is a dress code show and concessions will be available. Read More
  • Alexander, Blackburn introduce Legislation to Protect the TWH tradition

    United States Senators Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) and Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) today introduced legislation to protect the Tennessee Walking Horse tradition... Read More
  • Third Graders Meet the TWH

    Third grade students from Thomas Magnet Elementary School in Shelbyville, Tennessee toured the city of Shelbyville last week with one stop being the Celebration grounds. Celebration CEO Mike Inman spoke to the kids explaining the significance of the Celebration to the local economy... Read More