Skip to content

Did HSUS Mislead its Insurance Company or a Federal Court



reposted from HumaneWatch.org

The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) is still facing blowback from the more than decade-long litigation drama involving several animal rights groups, including HSUS, and their alleged racketeering scheme against Feld Entertainment, owner of the Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus. The latest issue? Whether HSUS misled its insurance company—or a federal court.

As readers may recall, a cohort of animal-liberation extremists sued Feld Entertainment, alleging elephant abuse, and lost. Adding insult to injury, however, was the ensuing countersuit. The court found that the activist’s key witness—a former circus employee who lied under oath—had been paid almost $200,000 by the plaintiffs and their attorneys, prompting Feld to bring a federal RICO lawsuit against the animal extremists.

While HSUS was not involved in initially bringing the animal-rights lawsuit against Feld in 2000, the group merged with the Fund for Animals (FFA)—one of the original plaintiffs—in 2005 while the litigation was ongoing. Usually, HSUS has no problem taking credit for the work of its affiliates—except, apparently, when this affiliation involves a federal RICO lawsuit. With racketeering allegations on the table, HSUS was quick to distance itself from the Fund for Animals, insisting that the 2005 marriage did not qualify as a merger.

According to HSUS CEO Wayne “I don’t love animals” Pacelle, FFA was separate from HSUS, with “its own board of directors and its own donors.” HSUS filed a motion to dismiss the RICO suit on this premise of organizational separation. According to court records, HSUS argued that while it “join[ed] forces in a corporate combination” with FFA, the two organizations did not merge and therefore HSUS wasn’t liable for any of the allegations. (Never mind, of course, that at least one payment to the witness was made on an HSUS check.)

Before the suit progressed to trial, HSUS joined the other animal radicals in forking over a combined $15.75 million to settle the litigation, covering Feld’s legal fees incurred by the “frivolous and vexatious” 14-year crusade.

HSUS released a statement responding to the multi-party settlement, explaining: “We expect that a substantial portion, if not all, of the settlement costs to The HSUS and The Fund for Animals will be covered by insurance, and in the end, that no donor dollars from The HSUS will go to Feld.”

One problem: HSUS was denied insurance coverage. The solution? Evidently, yet another lawsuit: HSUS sued its insurance provider. But now, it looks like three times won’t be a charm for HSUS.

National Union Insurance Co.—which denied HSUS’s request for coverage—has filed a motion for summary judgment in the suit brought by HSUS. Its motion sheds light on new evidence of glaring factual discrepancies in HSUS’s claims.

A December 2005 insurance application disclosed as an exhibit in the motion asked whether HSUS had merged with any other organization in the past ten years. HSUS answered “yes” and identified the Fund for Animals as the organization and “1/1/05” as the date of the transaction. The application was signed by Wayne Pacelle, and contained a representation that “the statements set forth herein are true.”

To recap, HSUS told a federal court that HSUS and FFA did not merge in 2005. Now, evidence shows that HSUS separately asserted that HSUS and FFA did merge.

By all accounts, there seems to be just two possible explanations: HSUS either misled the court, or misled its insurer. Maybe the several dozen lawyers on HSUS’s staff can try to make a “depends upon what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is” argument, but it seems likely to us that HSUS made the argument to the court because it was more convenient than intellectually honest.

Ethics apparently isn’t a priority at HSUS. After all, this is a group that uses cats and dogs to bring in millions of dollars despite not running a single pet shelter. When will they finally be held accountable?

More Stories

  • Latest Issue 10 21 19

    Read More
  • TWHBEA announces 2019 election results for 2020-2022 term

    TWHBEA announced the 2019 election results for the 2020-2022 term. See below the 2019 winners and runners up for the International Board of Directors. The term is to be served Dec 1, 2019–Nov. 30, 2022... Read More
  • Unanimous champions to receive some extra bling

    Everyone within the horse industry knows what it means when a horse and rider are called out of the line up as the “unanimous champions.” Indicative of an across-the-board first place win, a unanimous winner has received the winning nod of not just one judge, but the entire three- or perhaps even five-judge panel. Read More
  • NAS hosts information session about inspection study

    The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NAS) hosted its first meeting Wednesday Oct. 16 to unveil details regarding its upcoming study to review the methods for detecting soreness in horses... Read More
  • Latest Issue 10 14 19

    Read More
  • NAS to host first meeting

    The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NAS) will host the first meeting of the study to review the methods for detecting soreness in horses on October 16, 2019. A portion of the meeting will be open to the public beginning at 11:00 AM ET with a welcome from Committee Chair, Dr. Jerry Black... Read More
  • Celebration attendance among students way up

    The Celebration has been giving thousands of horse show tickets to the students for the past several years, but this year the Celebration Board took a different approach in an attempt to reach the masses and it worked... Read More
  • Equine Obituary – She's Push In Command

    She’s Push in Command was humanly euthanized in the early hours of Saturday, October 6, 2019, due to a chronic stifle injury. Known as Harley (or Big Momma) to those who loved her, she was bred and raised by Johnnie and Harriet Abrams of Waco, Kentucky. Harley was purchased as a yearling in 2003 by CM, Connie, and Lindsay Hess of Harrisonburg, Virginia.  Read More
  • NCWHA TIP Show canceled

    The NCWHA TIP Show, scheduled for Saturday, November 9, in Dallas, North Carolina has been cancelled. Read More
  • Baileyton Fall Classic updates class schedule

    The Baileyton Fall Classic, scheduled for Oct. 12, has added the following classes to their schedule...

    Read More