Skip to content

Letter To The Editor - Frank Eichler

We have just taken our first step in changing the Tennessee Walking Horse Industry with the establishment of the SHOW HIO and the dissolution of the National Horse Show Commission. I want to thank everyone for their support in getting us to this point. I also want to thank everyone who opposed these decisions. With your questions, concerns and criticisms we were able to develop a better solution. I also have a request but before I get to that I’d like to describe for everyone the process that allowed us to get to this point.

After the 2008 Celebration there were numerous conversations that took place within the industry about what to do next, how can we move forward with the industry, what to do about all the problems we have and the other typical questions we have always raised. I think there was a genuine concern but, as in the past, no real sense of urgency or passion that something had to be done. And then the economy took its tumble. This impacted everyone from the Owners who decided to put horses on board or took them home rather than leave them in training, to the Trainers who saw their income stream drop dramatically, to the business that relied on the TWH industry and to those businesses that benefited from the Industry who all saw their revenue and lives affected by the decline in the economy and the TWH industry. I don’t think there was any one clear item that caused the greatest concern; but then the governments scar rule clinic happened. And it was now crystal clear the TWH performance industry had to change.

As some of you may have read or heard a meeting was ultimately requested of the "decision makers" from each organization. There was no intent to exclude any organization or individuals but only a practical request to try and keep a manageable group to help facilitate discussions. Ironically most if not everyone agreed to come, and even with the snow we received in Shelbyville that Sunday we still had the majority of the group present – all total over 20+ individuals from the Trainers, Owners, Celebration and several others. It was a very interesting day. We talked about various alternatives, the pros and cons of each, we debated, agreed, disagreed and ultimately came to the conclusion of the first day with 2 proposals; Ask Donna Benefield to be the CEO of the NHSC reporting to an Independent Board or disband the NHSC and ask the SHOW HIO to take over reporting to an Independent board and ultimately being spun off from The Celebration. It was agreed that everyone would think about the 2 suggestions and meet again the next morning. Given all the recent speculation I want to also make it clear that there was no discussion about disbanding any Organization. In fact there is a need for each Organization’s support in either structure and this is not an attempt to eliminate the WHTA, WHOA or Breeder’s. Some of the responsibilities of various organizations that have historically been so vital to our industry (WHOA, WHTA, etc) will change, however, their importance will increase. During this time of change, the organizations have a unique opportunity to re-define themselves and assume new roles that will help as we all invest in moving the industry forward

It sounds simple but it was anything but. There was great passion for all the alternatives. There was great concern for each alternative. There was ultimately complete agreement that the Industry had to do something and it couldn’t be a band-aid – we needed a long term solution. It was also agreed that there was no perfect solution. Nor were there any guarantees.

We met the next morning and the group started where we left off. We discussed the pros and cons of both alternatives. We discussed slight changes to each alternative. And then we voted – unanimously to disband the NHSC and ask The Celebration to implement its SHOW HIO and the new structure. To be very clear The Celebration did not ask for this nor do they ultimately want this. David Howard offered to resign from The Celebration Board if that was an issue. The Trainers, although very professional and respectful gave up a lot in disbanding the NHSC after over 30+ years – I‘m not so sure I could have been as gracious. And the Owners and others present also struggled with the decision.

So what’s in it for everyone? A chance to correct the misperceptions and problems that are endemic in the current structure. What promises or commitments were made? None. Why am I doing this? I love watching my wife show her horses. Whether she wins, gets a ribbon or the gate she loves it and I want to help her continue to enjoy showing. And I believe as did our group that we are at a crossroads where something drastic has to change. To be very clear it was a very difficult decision and it gives the Industry a chance to survive, prosper and grow. However there is no guarantee. Please understand that this is not the final solution, but only a beginning. First, we must show the USDA and the world that we can show sound horses. This will require total cooperation with and from the USDA to improve our DQP inspections. Then, as SHOW achieves independence, bring together all the industry HIO's. It should not matter whether one shows under the banner of the National or WHOA or TWHBEA or WHTA. I am sure that we all will welcome that day.

Now my request. Whether you supported the decisions or were against them. Whether you like the people involved or not. Please be part of the solution. There will be many bumps ahead and there are no sure things. SHOW and its management need our support, input and confidence. A house divided against itself can not stand, but together we can succeed. So please let’s come together for this great horse and industry and fight the common enemy – the sore horse. The next time you see someone leading a sore horse say something. The next time you hear an owner or spectator saying they want or like a really deep sore horse say something. Instead of saying negative things about each and every decision please give it a chance and provide constructive suggestions. The road we were on was, in the opinion of most everyone in the process, a dead end. This at least gives a fighting chance for a positive outcome. We can succeed and prosper if we all come together. And the group that met for 2 days and struggled with these decisions did just that. They have led by example and put aside their differences, disagreements and personalities and unanimously agreed on a way forward. Please support this great horse.


Frank Eichler

More Stories

  • Equine Obituary – Watch It Now

    It is with great sadness that we announce the loss of Watch It Now due to complications from colic... Read More
  • South Central Kentucky Walking Horse Association cancels banquet

    The South Central Kentucky Walking Horse Association has canceled their annual banquet for 2021. The association hopes to host their banquet in 2022. For more information, contact Frankie Jo Bradley at 270-6460-7957. Read More
  • APHIS posts 2020 enforcement activity summary

    The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has posted their fiscal year 2020 enforcement activity summary... Read More
  • Museum to receive 1946 copy of Blue Ribbon magazine

    The Walking Horse Report recently received a copy of a 1946 Blue Ribbon magazine.  The copy was sent by a Report subscriber Robert Smith in Elma, Wash... Read More
  • NAS makes recommendations regarding inspections

    The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine (NAS) released their report, “A Review of Methods for Detecting Soreness in Horses,” earlier today. The committee has been working on the report for over a year with their first meeting happening in October 2019... Read More
  • USDA to host virtual training for HIOs

    The United States Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Services has informed the industry’s Horse Industry Organizations that it will host a virtual training this year due to ongoing conditions surrounding the Covid-19 pandemic.  Read More
  • Kentucky HIO makes plans for 2021

    The Kentucky HIO recently announced updates for the 2021 show season. The HIO will lower horse show affiliation fee to $50 and maintain the $6 inspection fee per horse this year... Read More
  • Get the news…FAST

    It has been a year! The Walking Horse Industry remains strong and our supporters continue to dedicate their time and efforts to ensuring our future. Sales have seen record-high numbers and barns continue to bustle with the talk of the “next great one.”  Read More
  • WHTA seeks new office manager

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association (WHTA) has posted an opening for its office manager position. The WHTA will begin taking applications immediately.  Interested applicants should send their resume to the WHTA at PO Box 61, Shelbyville, Tenn. 37162. Read More
  • Obituary – Dr. Gordon DePoyster

    Harold "Gordon" DePoyster, 78, of Greenville, died Tuesday, January 12, 2021, at 3:00PM at Owensboro Health Regional Hospital. Dr. DePoyster was born October 5, 1942, in Muhlenberg County. He was a dentist and a member of First Christian Church in Greenville... Read More