Skip to content

Letter To The Editor-From Chuck Cadle



 

 

 

 

Dear Christy,
 
         I just obtained a copy of the Walking Horse Report and wanted to offer a correction to the article entitled, "TWHBEA Signs The Operating Plan." TWHBEA did not sign, TWHBEA's HIO signed at the direction of the HIO Committee. The following are the reasons our HIO signed the plan:
 
1. All those HIOs that sign the plan receive "sub delegate" initial enforcement authority.
 
2. All those HIOs that sign the plan receive the right to work with the APHIS to make amendments to the plan. Those that do not sign can still speak/lobby to the USDA to make changes but they do not have an inherent right to change anything.
 
3. The APHIS retains all authority to enforce the HPA - the Operating Plan does in no way preclude enforcement actions that the USDA feels necessary.
 
         During my recent AP interview, I was asked about the penalties and the removal of the probation period within the new plan. My response was that the USDA is "serious" about enforcement of the HPA. We will work with the APHIS to reach a consensus on penalties. I also mentioned that the Operating Plan penalties seemed far less than those of state laws like Tennessee where criminal actions can be taken against violators and I asked the AP why Tennessee was not enforcing the law. It seems that some legislator in Tennessee should be receiving a call. Maybe the HIO DQPs should be "deputized" by state authorities that have laws like Tennessee.
 
New Info:
 
         I have read the letters from the NHSC, Heart of America Walking Horse Association and the KY Horse Industry Organization. I do see a compromise solution to the concerns of these organizations and will be responding to them this week in an effort to set a meeting that will allow us to resolve this matter in favor of our industry. TWHBEA puts at the top of its agenda the formation of an independent event standards board that will oversee judging and inspections that are uniform throughout the nation and that can become a model for our international enthusiasts. We owe it to our industry to recognize that it is a new day and that change is inevitable. 
         I know that the transition to new training methods will cause some inherent challenges to trainers that are attempting to work with horses that do not have a squared gait. We at TWHBEA need to help these trainers and to work with the trainers’ association to make this transition easier. Using our collective experience, we can adopt training methods that are acceptable.
         I am sure that we will be successful. I am optimistic that over the next few weeks our industry organizations will develop an approach that will allow us to focus on our youth, our events and our respective businesses rather than our differences.
         I look forward to picking up the Walking Horse Report and reading only positive news. Together we can make it happen and I am going to dedicate my time over the next few weeks to meet with as many trainers, owners and HIOs as possible.
         TWHBEA is not the adversary. We are only interested in doing the right thing, and bringing integrity and fairness back into this industry is the right thing. 
 
My best,
Chuck Cadle
CEO and Executive Director 
TWHBEA
 
 
(Editor’s note: The following is a description of the TWHBEA’s Event Standards Board and its mission.)

The effort to maintain the status quo ended when the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders’ and Exhibitors’ Association (TWHBEA) asserted itself and assumed the industry leadership role by implementing a two phase initiative. Phase 1 introduced the TWHBEA sponsored Sanctioning Plan which created an “independent” HIO Committee to: (i) establish uniform standards; (ii) create the Tennessee Walking Horse Rule Book; (iii) enhance the training and standards for Designated Qualified Persons (DQPs); (iv) recruit, and make available to all events, independent accountable judges of integrity; and (v) recruit the participation and support of all Horse Industry Organizations (HIOs). Phase 2 will be the formalization of the Tennessee Walking Horse Event Standards Board which may consist of four independent committees with oversight authority for: (i) Rules; (ii) Designated Qualified Person (DQP) horse inspection quality review; (iii) Judges training, accountabilit, and related standards; and (iv) research and technology.
The motivation for this bold new initiative was:

1.         To eliminate any rewards for perpetuating the egregious practice of soring.
(a) The TWHBEA now refuses to recognize any show results from non-sanctioned events in its national high points system;
(b) The TWHBEA now refuses to recognize on its Internet Pedigree Software any show results from non-sanctioned events;
(c) The TWHBEA now records violations and suspensions that would aid owners in evaluating trainers, and in making horse purchase decisions; and
(d) Through enhanced inspections and quality judging at sanctioned events, sore horses will not receive prize money and ribbons, and those engaged in soring practices will not enjoy the added benefits of multiple sales of horses and increased stud fees. Additionally, the pressure to continue soring a recently sold sore horse in order to meet the new owner’s expectations will be terminated;

2.         To extend the United States Department of Agricultures (USDA) efforts in the enforcement of the Horse Protection Act (HPA), as well as the various states enforcement of their own animal cruelty statutes. In addition, by the adoption of one inspection Rule Book and strict uniform standards for inspections that have already been reviewed and accepted by the USDA, any newly sanctioned HIO will not be required to submit their version of rules and standards, and the USDA will not be required to expend their funds and manpower to review them;

3.         To establish a uniform set of standards through one Rule Book, one inspection process, and one judging criteria to be used in all Tennessee Walking Horse events, irrespective of where or when they may be held or by whom they might be sponsored;


4.         To create enhanced and more rigorous training of DQPs and Judges resulting in heightened expectations and greater accountability, and to create an independent system of oversight by the employment of one Director of Animal Welfare and one Director of Judges for the benefit of all sanctioned HIOs;

5.         To implement material and meaningful independence and transparency in an HIO Committee by having the TWHBEA act as the Sanctioning Plan sponsor with a veto vote. The HIO Committee is not in appearance or in actuality comprised of the very trainers and owners that are being evaluated at events. A further demonstrable extension of this independence is in the constitution of the TWHBEA’s general membership, a majority of whose primary interest is in the pleasure and trail flat shod Tennessee Walking Horse;

6.         To provide needed funding for research and technology, and a methodology and repository for grants, federal, state and private; and

7.         To comply with the intent of Sarbanes Oxley (2002) and bring integrity to the industry. The Sarbanes Oxley Act established a new quasi-public agency, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board which was charged with overseeing, regulating, inspecting and disciplining accounting firms in their roles as auditors of public companies. The Tennessee Walking Horse Event Standards Board would also act as a quasi-public agency and through the TWHBEA Sanctioning Plan it would oversee, regulate, inspect and discipline HIOs, DQPs, and judges under uniform standards and rules to be used by all events.

8.         To provide the same standards to the international community.

More Stories

  • **Updated Horse Show Schedule

    The Walking Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse shows... Read More
  • Get the news…FAST

    What a wonderful show season we have had so far this year! The Walking Horse Industry has made the best of a bad situation and showed up and showed out! We have seen some fantastic horses and huge shows already this year... Read More
  • Latest Issue 8 17 20

    Read More
  • 42nd WHOA International Face Masks

    Previously, WHOA announced protocols for the wearing of face masks during the International. Masks are required per county, and MTSU regulations. Wearing a mask in the show ring is not required while mounted, and handlers of Weanlings, Yearlings, Model, In-Hand or, Showmanship in the show ring. Masks are required in the Warm-up arena. Read More
  • WHTA moves Trainers’ Show to October

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Association has its National Trainers’ Show on the move again. In what can only be considered a crazy year, the National Trainers’ Show was supposed to be held March 19-21 at Calsonic Arena in Shelbyville. And then the coronavirus came to wreck all sports including the Trainers’ Show... Read More
  • Obituary – James Wilkerson

    James C. Wilkerson, age 79 of Maryville, passed away Saturday, August 8, 2020. James was the owner and president of Serviceway Motor Freight Inc. for over 35 years. He was a member of the Jaycee’s and the Knoxville Motor Transport Association... Read More
  • Grace Baptist Church to conduct Celebration Worship Service

    The Celebration recently was contacted by Jeffrey McGee of Grace Baptist Church regarding the opportunity to continue the tradition of the Celebration worship service on Sunday morning of The Celebration. The opportunity became available after Pastor Steve Murphree decided not to conduct the service this year. Read More
  • North Carolina Championship canceled

    Due to Covid-19 restrictions, the North Carolina Championship Horse Show, scheduled for October 8-10, has been canceled for this year. The North Carolina Walking Horse Association is already beginning their planning for a better experience in 2021... Read More
  • Live from International Grand Championship

    ReporTV will provide live streaming coverage from the 42nd annual International Pleasure and Colt Grand Championship, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, beginning at 4:00 pm each evening... Read More
  • Message from the President of the Alabama Walking Horse Ladies Auxiliary

    I hope everyone is planning to attend the 9th Annual AWHLA Horse Show. From the sound of things, it looks like we are going to have a great show... Read More