Skip to content

The $16 Million Elephant in the Room

reposted from

Last month, the Washington Times editorial board published a piece, “The inhumane society,” detailing the dishonesty of HSUS—epitomized, the paper argued, by the group’s contributions to a 14-year smear campaign (coordinated by HSUS and other animal-rights radicals) to ban elephants from the circus. Those who follow our efforts know how this movie ended: Ultimately, a federal court uncovered a scheme in which activists paid a key witness—who lied under oath—almost $200,000. The judge called this witness “essentially a paid plaintiff and fact witness who is not credible” and deemed an animal-rights lawsuit against the circus “frivolous and vexatious.”

As a result, Feld Entertainment, which owns Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey, brought a federal racketeering lawsuit against activists, resulting in HSUS and the other animal extremists writing a $15.75 million check that covered Ringling’s legal fees, wreaked by the prolonged crusade. (ASPCA, another organization named in the suit had already settled its part for $9.3 million.)

HSUS seems to think that animal lovers shouldn’t be phased by its settlement. In a letter responding to the Times’ editorial, HSUS spokesman Alan Heymann explained that the lawsuit was “settle[d] earlier this year,” and that the group “continues to be transparent about where donor dollars go.”

This insistence on transparency is surprising, given HSUS’s statement following the settlement. HSUS claimed that “no donor dollars from The HSUS will go to Feld.” That seems to be misleading at best, and perhaps outright false. HSUS’s insurance company denied it coverage regarding the RICO suit. HSUS has sued its insurer to try to get coverage, but there’s no guarantee HSUS will win—and the RICO lawsuit settlement was already paid in May.

Our polling also contradicts HSUS’s claims of ongoing “transparency and good stewardship of donations.” Last year, over 1,000 self-identified donors to the Humane Society of the United States reported that they supported the group “to help HSUS care for animals in shelters.” Upon learning that only 1% of the HSUS budget is used for this end, 84% of HSUS’s benefactors agreed “HSUS misleads people into thinking that it supports local humane societies and pet shelters.” That doesn’t exactly sound like transparency and good stewardship.

If you don’t take our word for it (or the words of the group’s very own donors), consider the evaluations of objective third-parties: Charity Navigator pulled HSUS’s rating and replaced it with a warning to donors. And the charity evaluator CharityWatch routinely gives HSUS bad grades on its report cards.

This isn’t Heymann’s first flop, either. Last year we told Bloomberg News about a complaint we filed with the IRS due to HSUS’s apparently filing of incorrect tax returns for years. HSUS had been wrongly inflating its finances against IRS instruction. Heymann’s brainless response in the story was “The only thing I would ask is that you consider the source of these allegations.” Well, Bloomberg did consider the source—and the facts—and ran the story. And in its most current tax return HSUS has changed the way it reports some of its income—presumably as a response to our allegations.

HSUS claims the Times is issuing “ad-hominem, false attacks” at the allegedly “respected” HSUS. But the facts speak for themselves, and a group that trades on the generosity of others to attack farmers or pay legal bills doesn’t earn any respect in our book.

More Stories

  • Latest Issue 7 6 20

    Read More
  • Get the news…FAST

    Hello Tennessee Walking Horse enthusiasts and friends,

    We are so happy to see so many of you finally enjoying horse shows this summer. We look forward to the continued support of these shows and hope everyone stays safe and healthy while attending...

    Read More
  • Marshall County Horseman's Association revises class schedule

    The Marshall County Horseman's Association Horse Show, scheduled for July 24 in Lewisburg, Tennessee, has added two classes to their original schedule... Read More
  • Birth Announcement – Charles Coy Sanderson

    Charles Coy Sanderson was born Tuesday, June 16, 2020 at Tennova Medical Center – Harton in Tullahoma Tennessee, to proud parents Clay Sanderson and Kasie Caldwell. Coy was born at 11:58 am, weighing 8 pounds, 2 ounces and measured 20.5 inches in length... Read More
  • **Updated Horse Show Schedule

    The Walking Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse shows... Read More
  • Money Tree Classic is a GO!

    There has been some concern about the The Money Tree Classic being held this Friday with the Governor’s extension of executive orders announced on Monday, June 29. The show can absolutely be held in accordance with the current guidelines... Read More
  • Online entry system live for 4th of July shows

    The online entry forms for Christmas in July, the Money Tree Classic, and the Woodbury Lions Club horse shows are all live... Read More
  • Message from WHTA President

    It is important that all trainers attending any shows secure their personal training supplies and equipment. The Fun Show was the second multi-day show that supplies & equipment came up missing. (Bridles, Saddles, Chain Carts, etc.) Read More
  • Tune into ReporTV this week!

    ReporTV will be providing live streaming coverage for our online subscribers from the following shows this week... Read More
  • USDA sends guidance to industry

    The United States Department of Agriculture's (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Services (APHIS) sent the following letter to provide guidance to the industry regarding the steps they will take to ensure their safety and the safety of others when their inspections resume... Read More