Skip to content

Supreme Court Decision Holds ALJs Must Be Appointed



The United States Supreme Court has ruled that Administrative Law Judges must be appointed by the department head and not how they are currently retained by the agency they represent.  The case, Lucia vs. the Securities and Exchange Commission, does not deal with administrative law judges in the USDA, however the ruling could have a major impact on the enforcement scheme currently utilized by the USDA in Horse Protection Act cases.

It is not clear, nor did the Supreme Court Justices recommend, what the solution is for however they did remand the Lucia case back to be heard by a constitutionally appointed officer and it can’t can be the administrative law judge in the previous case.  There are several cases involving walking horse exhibitors in the D.C. circuit on appeal in front of a judicial officer where attorneys have raised the same issue of the appointment of the judicial officer not being constitutional.  However, those appeals have not been ruled on at this point in time.
 

More Stories

  • Report Holiday Schedule

    This November 18th issue of Walking Horse Report will be the final issue before the Thanksgiving break. Each year the Report finalizes the show season and then has a break for Thanksgiving... Read More
  • Equine Obituary – Pusher's Fine Art

    Pusher’s Fine Art passed away November 18, 2019. Sired by The Pusher and out of Magic Robbie Lee, Pusher’s Fine Art was foaled on March 15, 1992. He was 27 years old... Read More
  • Remembering a Friend: Charles Burton Howard

    Charles “Charlie” Howard passed away November 5 after an extended illness at Vanderbilt Hospital. Despite the fact that he had battled infections since April, and had mostly been hospitalized since August, his friends and family are stunned at his loss... Read More
  • Louisville, Ky. City Council Urges Passage of PAST Act

    On November 7, 2019 the Louisville City Council unanimously approved a resolution, introduced by Council member Marcus Winkler, urging the United States Department of Agriculture to reinstate the final rule that was adopted in 2017 but never finalized after the election of President Donald Trump... Read More
  • Obituary – Thomas Sumners

    Thomas Brown Sumners passed away November 7, 2019. The funeral was held at Bills-McGaugh & Hamilton Funeral Home on Saturday, November 9, 2019 and was buried at Lone Oak Cemetery... Read More
  • Cammack's Featured in Local Texas Paper

    Blake Cammack and son Jackson Cammack were recently featured in an article in the Longview News Journal, their local paper in Texas. The Cammack's were featured regarding their success at this year's show and the accolades both accomplished this year. Read More
  • High Point correction deadline approaching

    As the season comes to an end, the High Point Report is also soon coming to a close and we need your help! The Walking Horse Report is asking readers to have any changes needing to be made to their High Point standings to us prior to Nov. 22. Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 11 19

    Read More
  • THE Charles Howard CHALLENGE!

    Instead of flowers, friends of Charles B. Howard are challenging one another to donate $41 for 41 years of showing at The International. Proceeds will fund a Charles Burton Howard Memorial Challenge Trophy and a Charles Burton Howard Memorial Scholarship for FFA members... Read More
  • Obituary – Charlie Howard

    Charles Burton Howard, age 68, passed away November 5, 2019 at Vanderbilt. He was born in Lackey, Kentucky and was a resident of Rutherford County. He taught school in Hindman High School, Hindman, KY, Lebanon High School, and Blackman High School... Read More