Skip to content

USDA Comments On Fifth Circuit Ruling



The Walking Horse Report reached out to the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) seeking comment regarding the recent ruling of the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals that overturned the Minimum Penalty Protocol previously mandated by the USDA.  The USDA, through Tanya Espinosa did not directly answer the questions regarding if they would appeal or if this decision affected the decertification process for the SHOW HIO.  

The decertification of SHOW was based upon their initial failure to implement the Minimum Penalty Protocol during the lawsuit SHOW, Contender Farms and Mike McGartland filed and subsequently lost in district court.  The USDA did however issue the following statement to WHR:

"The U.S. Department of Agriculture's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service is currently working with our counsel to review the decision made by the Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit  and determine our next steps. We remain committed to our mission of eliminating the cruel and inhumane practice of soring, and we will continue to use rigorous inspections conducted by our trained and professional veterinarians and to maintain strong oversight of horse industry organizations to achieve this mission."

The Fifth Circuit left little doubt about the unconstitutionality of the rulemaking USDA implemented to force HIOs to enforce the Minimum Penalty Protocol.  The opinion stated, "In sum, the Regulation is an indisputably significant effort by the USDA to become involved in HIO enforcement procedures. Although participants in horse shows have always been subject to regulations from both HIOs and the USDA, the USDA has now taken intrusive steps into the private scheme to strengthen the penalties that HIOs must levy against those found to sore horses."

It went on to read, "The USDA purports to draw its authority to adopt the Regulation from several provisions of the HPA. Upon examining these provisions, we conclude that none of these provisions authorizes the Regulation but conversely, that these provisions plainly prohibit the Regulation."

More Stories

  • Cammack's Featured in Local Texas Paper

    Blake Cammack and son Jackson Cammack were recently featured in an article in the Longview News Journal, their local paper in Texas. The Cammack's were featured regarding their success at this year's show and the accolades both accomplished this year. Read More
  • High Point correction deadline approaching

    As the season comes to an end, the High Point Report is also soon coming to a close and we need your help! The Walking Horse Report is asking readers to have any changes needing to be made to their High Point standings to us prior to Nov. 22. Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 11 19

    Read More
  • THE Charles Howard CHALLENGE!

    Instead of flowers, friends of Charles B. Howard are challenging one another to donate $41 for 41 years of showing at The International. Proceeds will fund a Charles Burton Howard Memorial Challenge Trophy and a Charles Burton Howard Memorial Scholarship for FFA members... Read More
  • Obituary – Charlie Howard

    Charles Burton Howard, age 68, passed away November 5, 2019 at Vanderbilt. He was born in Lackey, Kentucky and was a resident of Rutherford County. He taught school in Hindman High School, Hindman, KY, Lebanon High School, and Blackman High School... Read More
  • Notice WHTA Members

    Anyone wishing his or her name be added as a candidate will need to notify the WHTA office or a member of the Nominating Committee no later than November 15, 2019 his or her intent to run for an officer or directorship (please specify which one)... Read More
  • Walking For Angels schedule and entries update

    The Walking For the Angels Horse Show, scheduled for Saturday Nov. 9 at 4:00 pm, has added the following class:

    Class 22A – Amateur Stallions Pony class

    Read More
  • Liz Kid's Show schedule update

    The following change has been made to the Liz's Kids Show schedule:

    The Novice Class changed to rider only. Class 7 is Novice Rider; no blue in 2018-19.

    Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 4 19

    Read More
  • Perryville, Missouri Show Combined with Mt Vernon, IL

    The Walking Horse Owners Association would like to announce that the rained out October 26, Missouri Horse show in Perryville has been combined with the November 2nd show in Mt Vernon, Illinois... Read More