Skip to content

Celebration Panel Includes Veterans and Newcomers



Meeting the wants and needs of its customers is considered good business sense. The judges committee of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration feels it met the wants and needs of its customers when it hired four of the top-five recommended judges from six different groups that were polled for their opinion.

Each year, letters are mailed to board members of the following organizations: National Horse Show Commission, Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders' and Exhibitors' Association, Walking Horse Owners' Association, and the Walking Horse Trainers' Association. In addition, members of the Tennessee Walking Horse Celebration Advisory Board and the Celebration's Young Trainers group are polled as to who they feel should judge The Celebration.

When the letters came back from the aforementioned groups, the following individuals received the most votes (in descending order of number of votes): Mike Carpenter, Jamie Hankins, Robin Edwards, Paul Watlington, Gene "Smokey" Carswell, Rollie Beard, Eddie Tuck, Jerry Woodlee, Brian Martin, and Wayne Dean.

Carpenter, Hankins, Watlington and Carswell join showing veteran Laura Brandon to make up the panel...a panel that has 12 previous Celebration judging stints to its credit.

"We feel we were able to put together (what I think will be) one of the best panels to ever judge the Celebration," said Celebration CEO Ron Thomas. "We received quality information and recommendations from the groups we polled. We just did not get nearly the amount of responses we would have hoped."

Out of the six groups, 115 individuals received a letter asking for their recommendation on the judging panel. Of those 115 letters, only 34 replied; or 29 percent. That is opposed to 65 percent response rate (51 to 78) from the same groups prior to the 2002 Celebration.

"Having such a low percentage of respondents is very disappointing," said Thomas. "You would think that anybody and everybody who has an opportunity to take part in such a poll for the world championship horse show of our breed would do so. The question we ask ourselves is 'what message are they sending us' when they don't respond?"

"We're not sure if it is a vote of confidence in the way we've selected judges throughout the years or whether it's the old political cop-out that their vote wouldn't mean anything anyway or simply a lack of interest," continued Thomas. "I think the Celebration board and judges committee has left no shadow of a doubt that they listen to the movers and shakers of this industry when it comes to this very critical and sensitive decision each and every year."

The most important factor when naming a judging panel for The Celebration or an officiating crew for any sporting event is to name the very best individuals available. In the Celebration's case, other factors are taken into account as well. These factors are looked at then putting together a good mix of people on the panel. Those factors can include geography, background in the industry, judging experience, the overall synergy of the group, ad intangibles.

"It's really no different from watching the NCAA Final Four or the NFL Playoffs," said Thomas. "If you're watching a college basketball game and John Clougherty's on the floor, you know that game will be very well officiated. The same goes for the NFL. If Jerry Markbright was on the crew, you knew it was a big game and it would also be officiated very well. They put their best officials in the biggest games. In our case, we want the best officials for the biggest game in the walking horse industry - The Celebration."

"There is no question that there are individuals in our industry who are regarded as, hands down, the very best judges available. Bottom line - the best judges in the industry should judge the best horses in the industry at the biggest and best horse show in the industry...and that's what we think we have put together again this year," Thomas remarked.

Carpenter leads this year's panel with seven previous Celebrations to his credit while Hankins has made three previous appearances while Carswell has judged the big show twice. Brandon and Watlington will be making their first-ever appearance on the judging panel after many years of showing at the Celebration.

The Celebration kicks off with day classes and the TWHBEA National Futurity on Wednesday, August 20 and will come to a close on Saturday, August 30. In between, over 5,000 entries will become part of the 65th renewl of the World's Greatest Horse Show.

For more information on The Celebration, log onto their website at www.twhnc.com or call 931-684-5915.

More Stories

  • Farm Bill passes

    The Farm Bill appeared in the headlines throughout 2018, including within the walking horse industry as an attempt was made earlier this year to include language in the bill that would have affected the walking horse industry... Read More
  • Check off the horse lovers on your list!

    Simply renew your subscription at regular price and order as many gifts at half price as you need to complete your holiday shopping in one simple step. Read More
  • Latest Issue December 10 18

    Read More
  • Obituary — Lester John Anderson, Jr.

    Lester John Anderson, Jr., 69, passed away Nov. 21at his home in Piney Flats, Tennessee. John’s career as a Tennessee Walking Horse trainer spanned many years. He thoroughly enjoyed working and showing these beautiful horses... Read More
  • Equine Obituary – My Bright Star

    World Champion, My Bright Star, passed away on Thursday, November 22, 2018, from complications of colic. My Bright Star was born on October 3, 1998. He was 20 years old... Read More
  • Election yields changes to TWHBEA’s executive committee

    Two contested positions that required a ballot vote as well a couple more uncontested nominations resulted in a TWHBEA executive committee for 2019 that looks quite a bit different from last year’s. The election closed out the nearly three-hour annual International Board of Directors meeting Dec. 1... Read More
  • 2018 Readers' Choice Ballot

    You don't have to be a member of anything to vote for your favorite horses, exhibitors, trainers and shows in The 37th Annual Walking Horse Report Readers' Choice conducted by The Walking Horse Report... Read More
  • Latest Issue December 3 18

    Read More
  • Positive trends and changes to Futurity highlight TWHBEA meeting

    The annual general membership meeting of the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders’ and Exhibitors’ Association (TWHBEA) was held Nov. 30 at the TWHBEA headquarters with approximately 40 members in attendance... Read More
  • TWHBEA honors 2018 awards

    The Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders’ & Exhibitors’ Association held its annual awards banquet on Friday, Nov. 30 at the TWHBEA Headquarters in Lewisburg, Tennessee. Following a welcome, the invocation and a delicious meal, the evening’s awards presentation began.  Read More