Skip to content

Court Grants Preliminary Injunction to McSwain



Keith and Dan McSwain have been successful in obtaining a preliminary injunction against the USDA in their inspection of Honors.  The conclusion of the ruling handed down by United States District Judge Richard W. Story stated:

"In accordance with the foregoing, the Court DECLARES that Plaintiffs have met their burden to show a substantial likelihood of success on the merits of their claim that Defendants' enforcement of the HPA violates the Due Process clause of the Fifth Amendment.  The Court GRANTS Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction.  Defendants are hereby ENJOINED from disqualifying Plaintiffs' horse, Honors, under the Scar Rule without providing Plaintiffs with adequate pre-deprivation process, including notice and opportunity to be heard."

The defendants in the case are Tom Vilsack, United States Secretary of Agriculture, and the United States Department of Agriculture.

The lawsuit filed by Keith and Dan McSwain was an action under the Administrative Procedures Act and the United States Constitution against the USDA for its failure to afford due process to those affected by its deprivation of property while acting under the color of federal law, for its failure to abide by its own rules, regulations, and procedures related to the Horse Protection Act, and for acting contrary to an in excess of the authority delegated to it by Congress.

The suit seeks a declaratory judgment from the court against the USDA for its failure to provide notice and hearing, thus violating the due process clause of the Fifth Amendment.  It also seeks declaratory judgment for failure to adhere to the scar rule and procedure for detecting violations as well as a preliminary and permanent injunction.  The McSwain’s also ask the court to reverse and set aside the Honors scar rule disqualifications and a recovery of their fees.

In receiving a preliminary injunction, the McSwain’s had to demonstrate: (1) they have a substantial likelihood of success on the merits; (2) irreparable injury will be suffered absent an injunction; (3) the injury to the movant outweighs the injury the proposed injunction would cause to the opposing party; and (4) the proposed injunction would serve the public interest.

The lawsuit points out many of the items the industry has complained to the USDA about regarding the application of the scar rule.  The suit points out the change in interpretation of the scar rule without any change to the HPA or Regulations, the misapplication of the anterior and posterior definitions for scar and the highly subjective nature of the inspection.

Pathology expert Dr. Paul C. Stromberg, DVM, PhD, concluded after the 2015 Celebration that the USDA’s method for enforcing the Scar Rule “ignores other possible causes and betrays a lack of understanding of basic pathologic principles.  It’s not medically rational or scientifically defendable.  It’s just pseudoscience and poor medical practice.”

The preliminary injunction granted by Judge Story is only a first step and the suit will continue to move forward in the coming months.  The USDA has not responded at this time to the granting of the injunction.

Click here to view the complete Order.

More Stories

  • ReporTV broadcast schedule

    ReporTV will be streaming the 2019 Walking For Cancer Horse Show, Sunday August 5, beginning at 6:00 pm. Read More
  • Celebration makes plan for Spring Fun Show

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration continues to make plans to hold the Spring Fun Show on its traditional Memorial Day weekend date. This year that date would be May 21-23. Given the uncertain status of the COVID-19 pandemic and its effects on events, the Celebration continues to also look at contingency plans. Read More
  • **Updated Horse Show Schedule

    The Walking Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse shows... Read More
  • Germantown Charity cancels annual show

    It is with heartfelt disappointment that the Germantown Charity Horse Show must announce the rescheduling of our June 2-6, 2020 show. Due to the outbreak of Covid-19, the 72nd Annual Show is rescheduled to June 8-12, 2021. Read More
  • Obituary – Jim H. Ellis, Jr

    Mr. Jimmy "Jim" H. Ellis, Jr. age 50 of Orrville, passed away on April 1, 2020 at Vaughan Regional Medical Center in Selma. He was born February 2, 1970 to the late Jimmy H. Ellis, Sr. and the Mildred Martin. Read More
  • A letter from the TWHBEA President

    First, let me say how proud I am to be part of this industry and Association. From the trainers along with Tony Edwards and others setting up and feeding those affected [by] the tornado in Nashville, to FAST providing gift boxes to our friends in the medical field... Read More
  • Medical Professional Salute: Joyce Marie Claxton

    The Walking Horse Report would like to thank you for your service to our nation, our communities and our Walking Horse Industry as we all try and deal with this pandemic that our country is facing... Read More
  • Obituary – Ruby Bilbrey

    Mrs. Ruby Bilbrey passed from this life on Wednesday evening, surrounded by her loving family. She was born in Overton County, Tennessee on November 21, 1931 to the late Charlie & Hessie Stover Parrott. Ruby was a 1953 graduate of Livingston Academy and a member of the Free Communion Church of Christ.  Read More
  • Upper Cumberland cancels show

    The Upper Cumberland Walking Horse Show, scheduled for May 9, at Hyder-Buks Pavilion in Cookeville, Tennessee, has been canceled. TTU has canceled all events at Hyder-Burk’s through the middle of May. Read More
  • Derby Classic postponed

    The Derby Classic, scheduled for May 2, in Harrodsburg Kentucky, has been postponed due to COVID-19. They hope to reschedule later this year. If you have already sent in sponsorship money, it will go toward the newly scheduled Derby Classic.   Read More