Skip to content

Donna Benefield - Expert or Hypocrite?



Donna Benefield has now teamed up with Congressman Ed Whitfield, HSUS’ Keith Dane, Marty Irby and Clant Seay (BillyGoBoy) to launch a concerted attack on the padded Tennessee Walking Horse, the Celebration and certain individuals.  Benefield has testified in front of the House Energy & Commerce Committee and made wild accusations such as witnessing horses standing in blood in the ring, making it seem that this is a common occurrence.  

Although providing no evidence of her accusations, her being called to testify as an “expert” was damaging enough.  Benefield has also stated that all padded performance horses are sore and stands in support of a bill introduced by Whitfield that would eliminate all pads, weighted shoes, and action devices and would eliminate the HIOs and turn over complete enforcement to the USDA.


Even more recently, Benefield has been extremely critical of the Celebration’s inspection program, the SHOW HIO.  Few people have had more access to the SHOW HIO than her.  She recently stated that she witnessed an industry veterinarian give a “nerve block” to a horse at the 2010 Celebration to help mask the pain when he went through inspection.  

It’s difficult to understand why she didn’t release the name of the veterinarian, the trainer involved or even the name of the horse because Donna was hired that year by the Celebration to monitor the grounds. She had the authority to stop the horse from coming to inspection and turn over to SHOW the information and have appropriate charges brought against the individuals involved.  What possible excuse is there to allow that to happen when she was being paid to stop exactly that kind of violation?
 
With her ego sufficiently stroked by her Celebration job Benefield did an interview at the end of that year on What A Horse where she spoke of her experience at Celebration and her opinions of the SHOW HIO.  Here are some excerpts from that interview.

When asked about what her role at the 2010 Celebration was, Benefield answered, “My job was the oversight of the Celebration in the inspection area, in the barns, working with the trainers and observing the horses in the warm-up ring, in the show ring and also out in the barns to make sure things were compliant.  And if they weren’t, then to address it and take care of it.”  

Either Benefield was not truthful in her accusation of the nerve block or she purposely allowed a horse to show in violation of the law and failed to perform her job as outlined by the Celebration.  You can’t have it both ways!

When Benefield was asked about her thoughts on the performance of the SHOW HIO and how it had done Benefield answered, “So based on January to now (November 2010), there has been significant change in the operation of inspections and the procedures, and they’ve gained, I think, a lot of credibility with both the public and the department.”

She further answered, “SHOW has really stepped up to the plate and improved the compliance and the inspection process.  And in my opinion, it’s probably the only inspection process at this juncture of the large ones that will probably save the performance horse for this industry.”

It makes you wonder if her opinion during that time was influenced by her pay from The Celebration or by her active interest in obtaining a job with the SHOW HIO.  And maybe her change in opinion regarding the SHOW HIO is influenced by some other entity’s pay or by a promise of employment from HSUS or Congressman Whitfield.  Remember, an unemployed Irby’s change of opinion landed him a job on Congressman Whitfield’s staff.

When asked about the difference in the USDA and SHOW inspection process, Benefield answered, “From what I have observed lately, SHOW is more thorough in their inspections, and their inspections are more in-depth.” 

She went further in supporting SHOW, “SHOW is significantly different.  I am willing to support any organization and inspection program that is moving towards reform.  And I see SHOW as being right now the leader in stepping forward, because their inspections are very thorough.”

It makes you wonder why then does Benefield support legislation that would do away with the SHOW HIO.  On that point, Benefield answered a question about the validity and effectiveness of one HIO.  “I think in an ideal world, one HIO makes the most sense.  But as long as we have a number of inspection programs that are as corrupt as some of them are, I think we’re going to need more than one HIO, because you do need to have at least one credible HIO.”

Benefield also supports the ban of the pad and action device which would eliminate the padded, performance Tennessee Walking Horse.  Is this a change or has Benefield always felt this way?  Well, she answered that as well, “That rumor has been out for a long time, and I don’t know where it came from, because I had padded horses.  And no, I’m not against the performance horse.”

Benefield is in favor of keeping the current subjective inspection process and not advancing the protocol with the use of science-based, objective testing.  Benefield also applauds the increase of penalties in the Whitfield bill for violations of the subjective protocol.  However, this too is a change in opinion for Benefield.  “Well, I’m pretty much on the record with the USDA that I’m opposed to that one-year suspension (for scar rule violations).  As I told Dr. Gipson with the USDA that until we solve the inconsistency in the interpretation of a scar, I don’t feel that it’s fair to put somebody out of business for an entire year.”  Benefield was so against this penalty, that her own HIO only issued a penalty of “back to the truck” when violations were found.

Now you realize that everything the industry is fighting for and all of the legislation by Congressman Blackburn and Senator Alexander once was supported by Benefield herself, who is now the champion for opposition to those thoughts and ideas.

And for good measure she had a strong opinion on the one thing killing the industry.  She stated for What A Horse on what is hurting the industry, “I would say—probably the thing that causes the most damage is some of these chat sites, because they spew out misinformation.  They mislead people.  They smear people.  They attack people and never let the facts get in the way of a good story.”

Everyone agrees with that but Benefield’s close personal relationship with Clant Seay and BillyGoBoy obviously has changed her opinion on that topic as well.  

When someone has views that are polar opposite depending on who is stroking them at the time of those comments makes you wonder if “expert” is an accurate way to describe them.  Hypocrite would be far more accurate.

More Stories

  • 2020 Readers' Choice Ballot

    You don't have to be a member of anything to vote for your favorite horses, exhibitors, trainers and shows in The 39th Annual Walking Horse Report Readers' Choice conducted by The Walking Horse Report... Read More
  • Celebration forms committee to help with class sheet

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration (TWHNC) hosted the first meeting of its newly formed class sheet committee on November 23, 2020. The committee consists of Nathan Clark, Justin Jenne, Jennifer Bingham, Laurie Toone, Howard Hamilton and Amy Trimble. Read More
  • Obituary – Ferne Eileene (Bauer) Crawford

    Ferne Eileene Crawford, age 92 of Georgetown, Ohio died Sunday, November 29, 2020 at the Ohio Valley Manor Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Ripley, Ohio. Ferne was a LPN at the former Brown County General Hospital, a former member of the Georgetown Police Department, the Brown County Dispatch office and the Brown County Auditor’s office. Read More
  • Obituary – Dianne Green

    Mrs. Sara Dianne Green, age 68, of Shelbyville, passed away Wednesday, November 25, 2020... Read More
  • KWHA postpones annual banquet and meetings

    On November 23, 2020, the Kentucky Walking Horse Association (KWHA) Board of Director’s met and voted to postpone the annual banquet, dinner, and general meeting that was originally scheduled for January 8-9, 2021 at the Embassy Suites in Lexington, Kentucky.  Read More
  • Obituary – Elizabeth Gassaway

    Funeral services for Elizabeth Marie Hestle Gassaway, age 48, of the Wheel Community, will be held 2:00 p.m. Sunday, Nov. 29, 2020, at Edgemont Baptist Church with Pastor Steve Murphree officiating and Laurie Toone speaking. Burial will follow at Jones Cemetery. Elizabeth passed from this life Thursday, November 26, 2020, at home surrounded by her loving family. Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 23 20

    Read More
  • Cyndi McConnell hospitalized

    The Report has recently learned that Cyndi McConnell has been in the hospital following a surgery to repair blockage in her heart. She has had two stints put in her main artery that was blocked 99%... Read More
  • Obituary – Michael Scott “Mike” May

    Michael Scott “Mike” May, age 79, of Shelbyville, formally of DeLand, Florida passed from this life Monday, November 16, 2020, at NHC of Tullahoma after an extended illness... Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 16 20

    Read More