Skip to content

Fifth Circuit Finds Inspections More Art Than Science



The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the district court’s ruling on the USDA Minimum Penalty Protocol on February 19, 2015.  The USDA initially introduced the new regulation in June 2012 however the Fifth Circuit reversed and vacated the district courts ruling and remanded the case for judgment in favor of Contender Farms and McGartland.

The industry, along with Rep. Marsha Blackburn and Senator Lamar Alexander have been pushing for more objective, science-based inspections and the Fifth Circuit agreed with the problems in the current inspection system.  “As the record indicates, inspections are far more art than science.  In many cases, inspectors, veterinarians and other professionals will disagree as to whether a horse is actually a sore.”

Another problem with the current subjective inspections for Tennessee Walking Horses is those inspections are not always accurate. The Fifth Circuit also agreed stating, “This Regulation targets soring, which is a practice that yields a large number of “false positives.”  Inspectors face significant difficulties distinguishing violators from non-violators.”

The court, veterinarian community, industry and even the humane groups have all recognized the current system of enforcement of the HPA is not effective.  The USDA was presented with an independent HIO in early February that would rely on independent, expert veterinarian leadership that will institute objective testing to eliminate soring.  The decision lies with the USDA to certify this HIO and begin the future of inspections in the industry that will eliminate the practice of “soring” and place the proper emphasis on the welfare of the horse.
 

More Stories

  • Obituary - Jim Pace

    John James Pace, Jr. (Jim), 80, of Tusculum passed away peacefully on Thursday, November 16th. He was a member of First Presbyterian Church and a retired farmer, cattleman, and horseman... Read More
  • Equine Obituary - Pride's Lady Dia

    The Report has recently learned of the passing of Pride’s Lady Dia, affectionately known as Lady Dia. She passed away on November 8, 2017, at Blackwell Stables, her home for the past 20 years. Read More
  • Equine Obituary - Hard Texas Cash

    Hard Texas Cash, a stallion owned by Nancy Groover Hodges of Waco, Texas. passed away on Nov. 8, 2017 at the age of 24... Read More
  • Equine Obituary - Heart Attack's Fast Beat

    World champion Heart Attack’s Fast Beat passed away on November 7, 2017. The 22-year-old gelding was owned and loved by Danielle Ricker of Greeneville, Tennessee... Read More
  • Celebration Of Life for Doug Crawford

    Please join us for the CELEBRATION OF LIFE Honoring Doug Crawford on Friday, November 10, 2017 at the Celebration Blue Ribbon Circle in Shelbyville, Tenn, 7-10 pm. Casual Attire. Read More
  • WHOO grants now available

    Applications for the Walking Horses Overcoming Obstacles (WHOO) grants are available now. The Walking Horse Trainers' Auxiliary is proud to award grants to 501(c)3 facilities that use Tennessee Walking Horses for therapeutic advancements of less fortunate individuals.  Read More
  • UCWHA announces nominations for 2018

    The Nominating Committee for the Upper Cumberland Walking Horse Association has nominated the followingdirectors for three-year term... Read More
  • Equine Obituary - The Coach

    The Coach passed away on November 4, 2017. At the time of his death, the 13 year-old stallion was owned by Dr. Barbara and Sarah Moersch of Jacksonville, Ala... Read More
  • Obituary - Virginia Chism

    Virginia Biddle Chism, 77, of Arrington, Tennessee passed away November 6, 2017. She was a lifetime member of, and elected to the Board of Directors of, the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders and Exhibitors Association... Read More
  • Obituary - Leona Kirby

    Leona Catherine Richey Kirby, 88, passed away Tuesday, Oct. 31, 2017, at Catawba Regional Hospice in Newton, North Carolina. She spent 25 years showing horses with her family across North Carolina, South Carolina, and Virginia. Leona and her husband, Floyd, also ran Tip-Top Stables together. Read More