Skip to content

Gulf Coast Inspections Point to Training Issues



As has been the case in many of the horse shows to begin the 2016 season, the USDA has put new Veterinary Medical Officers in the field to inspect.  These new VMOs in many cases have not been properly trained on the protocols of inspection found in the Horse Protection Act.  SHOW head Designated Qualified Person, Mitchell Butler has repeatedly pointed these inconsistencies out during the inspection process to head VMO Dr. Jeff Baker, however Baker will only reply, “they have been through the training.”

Butler has also asked Baker to allow the more seasoned VMO to check behind the new VMO just to confirm the findings since the new VMOs are not using proper technique yet the USDA will not allow a second VMO to confirm the findings of the first VMO.

In Panama City Beach, Fl. at the Gulf Coast Charity Horse Show, SHOW HIO inspected 205 entries pre-show.  Of those inspections, SHOW had horse show management disqualify 11 horses for violations of the SHOW rulebook.  Another three horses were not allowed to show at that performance for unacceptable, a determination that the DQP makes when the horse is not in violation of a specific rule but it unacceptable to show that night for another reason.  These horses are allowed to show back in another performance at the same horse show.

The 95% compliance rate was achieved with 11 horses being disqualified for eight unilateral rulebook violations, one foreign substance violation, one scar rule, and one horse was cited for both a bilateral rulebook violation and scar rule.

The USDA took information on 10 of those 11 horses as well as an additional 25 horses.  The USDA took information on 40 total violations on those 35 horses.  The USDA cited 13 bilateral, 13 unilateral, 12 scar rule, one foreign substance and one heavy chain.

A relatively new VMO in the rotation, Dr. McHenry, who according to multiple sources was not following inspection protocols, disqualified 11 of the 15 horses she inspected, or 73% of those horses.  The other two VMOs, who have also had complaints sent to the USDA regarding their techniques, Dr. Dominique Engel and Dr. Bart Sutherland had much lower percentages, 42% and 36% respectively.

Data collected by SHOW HIO and industry representatives continues to show the inconsistencies of inspection by USDA VMOs as well as the highly subjective inspection protocols that produce highly variable results.  SHOW HIO DQPs are certified and trained by the USDA each year.

One horse exhibited at the Gulf Coast Charity show, who did not want their name released due to fear of retaliation by USDA, has shown at five different shows this year with the USDA present and been inspected by VMOs at four of those shows.  At the Gulf Coast Charity show, the horse was shown and inspected pre and post-show the first time it showed and then inspected pre-show and passed the second time.  After its second performance, the same USDA VMO took information on a scar rule violation.

The easy fix for most all of the issues in inspection lies in one simple change, move from the current subjective inspections methods to science-based, objective inspection methods.  Veterinarians agree with industry testing of those science-based methods however the USDA, at the urging of the Humane Society of the United States refuses to meet to discuss implementing a more objective approach.

There is hope that new Deputy Administrator Bernadette Juarez might be open to exploring ways to strengthen the inspection process and remove the wild inconsistencies that exist today given her legal background but only time will tell.  

More Stories

  • Celebration to enforce dress code

    In keeping with the tradition and pageantry of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration, the Celebration would like to remind all exhibitors, trainers, owners and sponsors of the dress codes in center ring.  Read More
  • Celebration balances fan supply and demand for concessions

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration is unique from most sporting venues in how concessions are handled during the event. At The Celebration, tradition has been that area civic clubs rented space on the show grounds from The Celebration and sold concessions as a fundraiser for their club and the causes they serve.   Read More
  • Celebration Live Stream

    What A Horse will be providing the Live Stream for the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration and the TWHBEA National Futurity. Highlights will be posted the following day on ReporTV... Read More
  • Kentucky Celebration judges announced

    Judging the 2017 edition of the Kentucky Celebration will be Jamie Wiley, Kemp Martin and Randy Young. Read More
  • Meet the Celebration Judges

    The selection of judges for the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration is a process requiring layers of factors and careful planning by those behind the hiring. This year’s panel serves as a great example of what goes into that decision and why the panel is primed up with the potential to be a great one. Read More
  • USDA Rolls Out New APHIS Compliance Database and Search Tool

    The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) is pleased to announce the rollout of the refined public search tool that provides access to Animal Welfare Act compliance records... Read More
  • Marsha Prock remembers the Celebration

    The following thoughts and memories about The Celebration were submitted to Walking Horse Report by horse show enthusiast Marsha Prock... Read More
  • Obituary - Doug Crawford

    Mr. Douglas Clifford “Doug” Crawford, age 71 of Carrollton, Georgia passed away peacefully at his residence, surrounded by family and friends, on Sunday evening, August 13, 2017... Read More
  • Obituary - Priscilla Cash

    Three-time world champion Priscilla Cash was humanely laid to rest on August 14, 2017 after a long battle and lasting complications from EHV-1... Read More
  • Money Tree Fall Classic selects Robbins

    The Walking Horse Trainers' Auxiliary is proud to continue their support of the industry by hosting their first ever fall horse show. The Money Tree Fall Classic will be on Friday, September 22nd in Calsonic Arena at 6 P.M... Read More