Skip to content

A Look at The Fun Show Judging



By David L. Howard

Judging has come a long way and the ability to critique it has come even further!

Due to a health issue, I was unable to attend the Fun Show for the first time in its history but thankfully I could watch the live stream provided by Dean Johnson on the Walking Horse Report.com and check the final placing and judge’s cards after the class. This is a wonderful feature but there is noting quite like being there in person.

With little to do but stare at the walls, I also had time during my hospital stay to check comments about the Fun Show on our site as well as several other sites.

In this new age, the judges are not only being critiqued by the people at the show, several of the folks viewing the live stream had very strong opinions about some of the ties.  While I enjoyed the live stream, there is absolutely no way to get a complete picture of the class and have a realistic view of who won.  Sorry…can’t be done!

Personally, I quit “judging” the judges a long time ago… after I became a Corporate Sponsor at The Celebration and was in center ring for several classes on the final Saturday night.

It is easy to sit rail side and tie the top three and quite a bit different to be in center ring and tying anywhere from 6 to 10 horses.  At a show like the Celebration, the crowd noise and pressure are intense beyond belief but passing judgment on other people’s horses at any show is pressure packed.  There is a lot at stake in every class…from lead line to the Championship Stake.

Having said that, I decided to do my own analysis of the Fun Show working just from the cards.  I am not sure what the analysis shows but I found it quite interesting.

There were a total of 51 classes at the Fun Show.  There were 25 unanimous decisions (49%); two of the three judges tied the winning horse in 21 of the classes (41%) and there were 5 classes (10%) where all three judges tied a different horse.  In other words, in 90% of the classes at least two judges were in agreement on the winner.

As far as the individual judges, Joel Weaver tied the winning horse in 44 classes (86%); Nathan Clark tied the winner in 40 classes (78%) and Brock Tillman tabbed the winning entry 36 times (71%).

Not having been at the show, I can’t venture an opinion on these three fine judges, but looking at the cards it seems they were pretty much in agreement and very consistent.

More Stories

  • Live from International Grand Championship

    ReporTV will provide live streaming coverage from the 42nd annual International Pleasure and Colt Grand Championship, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday, beginning at 4:00 pm each evening... Read More
  • Message from the President of the Alabama Walking Horse Ladies Auxiliary

    I hope everyone is planning to attend the 9th Annual AWHLA Horse Show. From the sound of things, it looks like we are going to have a great show... Read More
  • Celebration implementing Covid-19 protocols

    The Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration continues to make preparations for the upcoming 82nd Annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration. The show will be held August 26 – September 5, 2020... Read More
  • Stake class splits announced by Celebration

    The 2020 Tennessee Walking Horse World Grand Champion will come from one of 14 horses that entered into the two qualifying classes that will be held Saturday evening August 29, 2020. The Celebration recently announced a 10% increase in entries for the 82nd Annual Celebration to be held August 26th – September 5th... Read More
  • Celebration Live Stream available throughout show

    Do you want to be at the 82nd annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration but can’t make it? Have no fear, because live stream internet is available to anyone not wanting to miss any of the action... Read More
  • Dog Show at The Celebration Cancelled

    The Walking Horse Trainers’ Auxiliary is sad to announce that the Dog Show held during the Celebration is cancelled. The Auxiliary feels that it is in the best interest of participants‘ safety to not host the event this year due to the COVID-19 pandemic... Read More
  • Obituary – Tony Nales

    Tony Nales of Fort Lauderdale, Florida passed away on August 2, 2020, after a courageous battle with cancer.  Tony, age 67, is survived by his wife of over 35 years, Terri Nales of Fort Lauderdale, Florida, along with four grown children, Anthony, Jr., Justin, Laura and Amy.  He is also survived by four young grandchildren... Read More
  • Obituary – Royce Couch

    Franklin, Tennessee resident and Warren County, Tennessee native, Royce Lee Couch, age 69, was born July 8, 1951 and passed away suddenly August 5, 2020 at his residence... Read More
  • Celebration entries up 10%

    With the uncertainty surrounding all of us currently, anticipation has been high to see the impact Covid-19 would have on entries at the 82nd Annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration. The 82nd Celebration announced 2,252 pre-show entries, an increase of over 200 horses from 2019... Read More
  • Celebration ribbons are ready!

    It’s that time of year again — the ribbons are ready and it’s time to roll out the red carpet for visitors in honor of the Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration Tricolor bows, symbolizing support of the show, run in various sizes and prices and are available an several local florists... Read More