Skip to content

Politics Still Makes Strange Bedfellows



Editors' Note: the following is reposted from the American Farriers Journal

by Jeremy McGovern 

No matter which side of the aisle that you prefer your elected officials to sit, we all can agree the U.S. presidential election and new administration have thrown prognostication and expectations out the window. Start with the wide assortment of candidates. Of course, this included former Rhode Island governor and plater Lincoln Chafee, whose campaign lasted about as long as the time needed to trim and shoe a horse. Then months and months of campaigning led to the stunning election results. Follow that with the inauguration and the continued inter- and intra-party fighting that brings us to where we are today.

So because the election cycle was so bizarre, then its influence on farriery was equally topsy-turvy. While it is too early to determine how policy will affect broad picture issues, such as how client income will be affected, which subsequently affects farrier income. Instead, the immediate affects arrived by how the USDA announced, backtracked, changed and then eventually failed in its attempts to address soring.

Things began in spring, as the USDA proposed changes to the Horse Protection Act (HPA). These proposed changes lacked definition and comprehensively lumped horseshoers together rather than specifying a breed or discipline. For example, the language indicated a full ban of pads, bands, toe extensions, and action devices, among others.


Hearings were held and the public’s input was collected. Months passed without clarification to the overriding concern that the proposed rule changes were too broad. The USDA amended the original proposal, but still failed to address the farrier industry’s concern.

Farriers dodged a bullet by the avoidance of the baby and bathwater soring for all performance.

After the election, but before the inauguration, the USDA did announce the final changes:

The final rule, which largely mirrors the bipartisan Prevent All Soring Tactics Act (H.R. 3268/S. 1121), applies only to Tennessee Walking Horses and Racking Horses. This is significant because the original language proposed Aug. 26, 2016, by the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS), included broad and ambiguous language that included breeds that “perform with an accentuated gait.”

“Congress passed the HPA to end the cruel and inhumane practice of soring horses and stop unfair competition,” according to a statement from APHIS. “Strengthening the HPA regulations and the enforcement of alleged violations is the best way to achieve this goal. In addition, the prohibitions on the use of action devices and pads (with certain exceptions) are consistent with recommendations made by the American Veterinary Medical Association, the American Association of Equine Practitioners, and leading industry standards for equestrian sports.”

However, as the new administration moved in, the USDA’s announced changes were halted and didn’t become law. So months and months later, we have the same soring regulations that we had before the USDA made the springtime announcement.

So all the hubbub and we’re back to status quo. That’s good news for farriers — unless you shoe Tennessee Walkers. Although it is unclear of this administration’s goals, the USDA hasn’t succeeded in enforcement and, in one case featuring a Tennessee farrier, demonstrated an embarrassing attempt to do so.

It remains to be seen what will happen with enforcement. Will the USDA abandon this altogether? What about their original broad proposal? Will legislation proposed by Tennessee Sen. Lamar Alexander go anywhere?

I would guess that we shouldn’t expect supply shops to hold clearance sales on pads anytime soon. But then again, who knows? If this past election cycle has taught us anything — expect the unexpected.

More Stories

  • Latest Issue 5 27 19

    Read More
  • Trainers gather for pre-Fun Show meeting

    A light crowd of about 20 gathered for the annual pre-show meeting among members of the Walking Horse Trainers’ Association at 4 p.m. Wednesday at the Blue Ribbon Circle on the Celebration grounds. The meeting served as the official opener of weekend events in conjunction of the Spring Fun Show.  Read More
  • LIVE from Spring Fun Show

    The Report will be providing LIVE coverage from all three nights from the Spring Fun Show on ReporTV this weekend. Highlights from the show will be posted the following day. There will also be LIVE results and judges' cards. Read More
  • EP outbreak doesn’t include TWHs

    A recent outbreak in Equine Piroplasmosis (EP) in Middle Tennessee has not been reported to include walking horses, although horses located in Bedford County are among the 22 horses that have tested positive for the blood parasite... Read More
  • Bedford County To Get New Upscale Community Designed For Adults 55 and Up

    H Global Investments and American Home Inc., announce plans to develop new community geared toward adults desiring luxury living with an eye toward their retirement years. Fieldstone will be situated on property located along Highway 231 North and Midland Road... Read More
  • FAST awards grant to Arab Football Booster Club Summer Classic

    FAST is pleased to announce that they are awarding a $1500.00 Grant to The Arab Football Booster Club Summer Classic. This show will be June 15, 2019, and is put on by The Walking Horse Association of Alabama. The FAST Board voted unanimously to approve this grant request. Read More
  • Palmetto Saddle Club Show rescheduled

    The Palmetto Saddle Club Horse Show, originally scheduled for May 18, has been rescheduled for November 2, 2019. Read More
  • WHOA Spring Classic at Harlinsdale Farm

    The Walking Horse Owners Association Spring Classic will be held this Saturday, May 18, 2019 at 10 am at The Park at Harlinsdale Farm in Franklin, Tennessee. This is a dress code show and concessions will be available. Read More
  • Alexander, Blackburn introduce Legislation to Protect the TWH tradition

    United States Senators Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.) and Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) today introduced legislation to protect the Tennessee Walking Horse tradition... Read More
  • Third Graders Meet the TWH

    Third grade students from Thomas Magnet Elementary School in Shelbyville, Tennessee toured the city of Shelbyville last week with one stop being the Celebration grounds. Celebration CEO Mike Inman spoke to the kids explaining the significance of the Celebration to the local economy... Read More