Skip to content

Pro-Farmer Protection On The Move In Missouri



Twitter is a great way to get the latest news, and yesterday we saw something that caught our eye: Two proposals in Missouri for constitutional amendments to protect agriculture. HJR 11 protects the right of farmers to raise livestock in a humane manner—a slightly different spin on amendments we’ve seen in other states, such as North Dakota’s Measure 3. Meanwhile, HJR 7 protects the right to hunt, farm, and fish.

Both Missouri proposals seem reasonable. But we really like this part of HJR 11:

No law criminalizing the welfare of any livestock will be valid unless based upon generally accepted scientific principles and enacted by the General Assembly.

This would cripple HSUS on two fronts. First it would require that HSUS propaganda be passed by the legislature, thus putting it up to significant scrutiny. It would rule out an HSUS ballot campaign using emotionally manipulative propaganda aimed at urban and suburban folks who don’t have experience with farm animals.

Second, it would require that any law regulating livestock welfare to be based on generally accepted scientific principles. Take one recent example, which sees HSUS is going around claiming that maternity pens for pregnant pigs are inhumane. HSUS is wrong on the science. The American Veterinary Medical Association and the American Association of Swine Veterinarians both find maternity pens provide for animal welfare. So, based on current animal welfare science, HSUS would not be successful in Missouri in banning pens.

Both proposals were introduced yesterday and HJR 7 has now apparently been folded into HJR 11, replacing the hunting and fishing text. So there’s now just one proposed constitutional amendment—to protect the right to raise livestock humanely—and it has already passed committee. You can read the full text here, though we'll note that the new bill does not have the language we analyzed above.

Proposed constitutional amendments require the legislature’s approval to be put on the ballot. If approved, this amendment would go on the ballot in Nov. 2014. Then, it would only require a simple majority to pass.

We’re always a fan of playing offense, and this is one way to do it and preempt future HSUS activism. We’ll see if this amendment inspires pushes in other states.

Reprinted from HumaneWatch.org

More Stories

  • Equine Obituary – Gold Sky

    Gold Sky was foaled on May 10, 2005 and passed away peacefully on September 9, 2021. He was proudly owned by BK and Jo Luna “56” of Sparta, TN. Read More
  • TWHBEA Bluegrass Classic canceled

    Due to conflicting with other shows, TWHBEA elected to move the TWHBEA Bluegrass Classic, scheduled for October 16, to next year. Read More
  • Obituary – Harold Roberts

    The Report has recently learned of the passing of long time walking horse owner and exhibitor, Harold Roberts of Van Burean, Missouri. A full obituary will be posted as it becomes available.  Read More
  • Obituary – Virginia Counts

    Virginia Gladys Counts, daughter of the late Henry R. Hatcher and Opal Gladys (Godden) Hatcher, was born in Logan, Iowa, on June 22, 1942. She departed this life at her residence in Republic, Missouri, on September 12, 2021, at the age of 79. Read More
  • Birth Announcement – Bennett Elizabeth Bobo

    Bennett Elizabeth Bobo was born August 20th, 2021 to parents Jason and Maria Bobo and proud siblings, Conlee Marie and Foster Clayton. She weighed 7 pounds, 10 ounces and was 19.75 inches long... Read More
  • Scholarships increased for TWHBEA Medallion program

    This year, through a partnership with the Marshall County Horseman’s Association, the Tennessee Walking Horse Youth Association is excited to announce an increase in the educational scholarships awarded in the Medallion Canter Program. Read More
  • Obituary – Michael Scott Adcock

    Michael Scott Adcock, 69, of York, beloved husband, father, grandfather, and brother, died peacefully at home surrounded by his family on Monday, August 30, 2021... Read More
  • ReporTV Interview with John Allan Callaway

    in the interview that follows, John Allan Callaway shares his thoughts after winning the Tennessee Walking Horse World Grand Championship with Justified Honors... Read More
  • The verdict is in for Celebration 2021

    On the premier night of the 83rd annual Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration perfect weather welcomed fans to watch 12 outstanding classes.  Read More
  • ReporTV Interview with Laurie Toone

    In the interview that follows, trainer Laurie Toone shares her thoughts after winning the Trail Pleasure Three and Under World Grand Championship with The Maiden.. Read More