Skip to content

Reinhart Comments On Horse Protection Case

Editor’s Note: The Walking Horse Report received the following letter from William Reinhart relative to his case that was reported on two weeks ago in The Report.

Dear Editor:
You have correctly reported that the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has dismissed my appeal on grounds of jurisdiction. The Horse Protection Act provides that you have 30 days from the date of the final order to file an appeal. The Judicial Officer in my case signed the final order on January 23, 2001. Thirteen days later I received erroneous material in the mail from the USDA relating to a completely different case. I called the hearing clerk for the USDA and advised her of the mistake and asked her about the status of my case. The clerk said there was no information available on my case. Ten days later - now an elapsed time of twenty-three days - the USDA clerk finally mailed by certified mail the correct order on my case which I did not receive until February 26 - a total elapsed time of thirty-four days. Consequently, my appeal was filed beyond the 30-day limit. The USDA admits all of these facts to the court.

Despite all of this, the Court of Appeals has ruled that I was supposed to check the docket and not depend on service from the USDA. The problem is that the USDA does not maintain a docket on cases before them nor publish in any form, a docket of cases. Therefore, the Court has placed on me an obligation which is impossible to comply with and places no responsibility on the USDA for their obvious foul-up. The rules of appellate procedure say that the clerk must immediately give notice when an order is entered.

The Court has cited several cases on the question which I believe are not relevant to the present case. All else the Court says in its order is dicta which has no effect on my case because they did not accept jurisdiction.

Adjudication through the courts is a tedious process which takes an enormous amount of time. The Court of Appeals even indicated that my remedy on the question of jurisdiction may lie with the U.S. Supreme Court. Despite all this, the court system is still the best mechanism to identify problems in our governmental system. After all, courts only interpret the intent of Congress through statutes they pass. There are at least two major questions that have come to light so far in my case that we should be asking our congressional delegation from Tennessee.

First, whether this is what they intended on the question of jurisdiction given the above facts. Congress, in passing the law, should have made the time of appeal to run from the date the order was received and not when it was signed.

The second question we should ask our congressional delegation is whether they intended for the Horse Protection Act to apply in our federal circuit which includes Tennessee and not in the 5th Circuit where that court has ruled twice that soreness detected through palpation of a horse’s feet is not substantial evidence to support a finding of soreness under the Horse Protection Act.

Stay tuned for the next episode of Federal Appeals Law 102.

Very Truly,
William J. Reinhart

More Stories

  • **Updated Horse Show Schedule

    The Walking Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse shows... Read More
  • Online entry system available for Alabama Jubilee

    The Alabama Jubilee, scheduled for October 23-24, will take online entries up until noon on Friday, October 23 and 11:30 am on Saturday, October 24. Entries can be made at  Read More
  • Obituary – Christy Kakassy

    The Report recently learned of the passing of long-time walking horse owner and exhibitor, Christy Kakassy, on Monday, October 19, after a difficult battle with acute myeloid leukemia... Read More
  • Latest Issue 10 19 20

    Read More
  • Equine Obituary – Pride's Jubilee Encore

    Sometimes a horse is destined for greatness and with the right group of people and a lot of hard work and determination, that level is reached. This was the case for 2001 World Grand Champion Pride’s Jubilee Encore... Read More
  • Dix River Fall Classic update

    The Dix River Fall Classic, scheduled for October 23-24, at the Brodhead Indoor Facility in Brodhead, Kentucky will be a SHOW–HIO show. The entry fee for flat-shod classes will be reduced from $30 to $15.  Read More
  • Thomas Seymore injured

    Thomas Seymore was injured during the Saturday evening performance of the Trainers’ Show. He was taken to Vanderbilt Medical Center with a broken ankle and other minor injuries... Read More
  • Larry Wheelon hospitalized

    Larry Wheelon is in the hospital in East Tennessee battling pneumonia and several other health issues. We extend our prayers to Larry and his family.  Read More
  • Bill Bobo hospitalized

    Longtime walking horse trainer Bill Bobo was hospitalized on Friday, October 9 at St. Thomas in Nashville, Tennessee. On Monday, October 12th, Bobo underwent open heart surgery to correct three blockages... Read More
  • Jimmy McConnell hospitalized

    The Report learned that Jimmy McConnell was hospitalized in Nashville, Tennessee following the Friday evening performance of the National Trainers’ Show. He suffered from a mild heart attack... Read More