Skip to content

SHOW and Contender Farms Dismiss Case Against USDA



On February 29, 2016, Contender Farms, L.L.P., the McGartlands, and SHOW, Inc. filed a lawsuit challenging the enforcement schemes utilized by USDA-APHIS. The complaint challenged the USDA’s use of three enforcement mechanisms not authorized under the HPA, and which directly contravene the requirement in §1825(b) that only the Secretary, after notice and hearing, can penalize a person for a violation. Plaintiffs challenged the USDA’s use of two unauthorized and unlawful administrative enforcement schemes: the “Protocol for Foreign Substance Penalty,” and the “IES Investigative and Enforcement Process,” under which the USDA wrongly decided that entrants, trainers and owners have violated the Act’s prohibition against entering sore horses. 

The Plaintiffs also challenged the USDA’s use of private party information about private inspectors’ activities, which the USDA used to falsely identify people as having been determined to have violated the Act.  Since none of these enforcement schemes were authorized by a Department regulation or by the HPA, this suit did not involve a challenge to any provision of the HPA or USDA regulation. The goal of the case was to obtain an order requiring the USDA to cease publishing numerous lists which falsely identified people as violators under the HPA, when a violation had not been lawfully determined.

Thousands of exhibitors have been wrongly identified as violators of the HPA without ever receiving notice and an opportunity to be heard before the Secretary, which is clearly required by the HPA. The plaintiffs in the suit had no problem with and did not challenge the publication of the identity of those parties who had this opportunity for hearing and either signed a consent decision or had their case adjudicated fully.  

On February 3, 2017, USDA-APHIS voluntarily complied with the requests made in the complaint and removed the misleading information from its web site.  As a result of this action by USDA, Contender Farms, the McGartlands and SHOW HIO have decided to dismiss the case without prejudice. The dismissal without prejudice gives the plaintiffs the right to refile the case should the USDA change course and republish the incorrect information.  

“Given the fact that we have achieved the primary objectives in the lawsuit and we still retain our ability to refile the case should the information be made public again, SHOW felt it was best to dismiss the complaint.  We commend the USDA for the removal of the information on their own accord, whether this case played a role in that decision or not.  With the removal of the lists, the public now has an accurate record of the industry’s record of over 99% compliance with the HPA. SHOW feels it would be better served to utilize resources in other areas that can make a larger impact on the welfare of the horses as well as the industry as a whole. The Celebration and SHOW HIO are committed to the development of more objective, science-based inspection processes which can accurately detect violators and remove them from participation.”

“We remain committed to enforcing the HPA through the SHOW HIO while also protecting our customers, exhibitors and sponsors from unlawful practices that damage their reputations,” said Tennessee Walking Horse National Celebration board member Jeffrey Howard.  The Celebration owns the SHOW HIO.

More Stories

  • Cy Webb to compete in Leal's Jr Bull Riding Championship

    Cy Webb will compete today, December 6, in the Short Go at the Leal's Jr. Bull Riding Championship at 11:00 am. The public can tune in for free at cowboychannelplus.com. Read More
  • Obituary – Sally Elaine Brown

    Sally Elaine Johnson Brown, age 68, went to be with her Lord, Wednesday November 3, 2021 at Centennial Hospital in Nashville, TN.  Read More
  • TWHBEA holds election

    After a lengthy and quite contentious meeting the Tennessee Walking Horse Breeders’ & Exhibitors’ Association (TWHBEA) conducted its annual election of its executive committee. Running unopposed and being elected by acclimation were the following... Read More
  • Latest Issue 12 6 21

    Read More
  • WHOA announces banquet date

    The Walking Horse Owners’ Association would like to announce that the WHOA Annual Awards banquet will be held Saturday, March 26, 2022. Read More
  • High Point Trainer of the Year

    Read More
  • 2021 Readers' Choice Ballot

    You don't have to be a member of anything to vote for your favorite horses, exhibitors, trainers and shows in The 40th Annual Walking Horse Report Readers' Choice conducted by The Walking Horse Report... Read More
  • Obituary – Gilbert Miller

    Mr. Gilbert Miller, 89, prominent Richmond, Kentucky businessman and developer, and the widower of Evelyn Rose Miller, passed away on Friday, November 26, 2021. Read More
  • FAST provides industry update

    In 2021, the walking horse industry has experienced a generally successful year for our show horse including an increased number of horse shows and sustained entry numbers at the 2021 Celebration.  As we enter into the final quarter of the year, industry organizations and leadership are turning their attention toward the 2022 year.   Read More
  • Obituary – Lined With Cash

    It is with heavy hearts that we announce the passing of Lined With Cash. He passed this afternoon of an apparent cardiac arrest.  This 25-year-old son of WGC Coin's Hard Cash out of the great Gen's Silver Lining has sired currently 1238 offspring who hold close to 400 World Titles. Read More