Skip to content

USDA Eliminating Sound Horses from Celebration Using Subjective Inspection Methods

SHELBYVILLE, TN – TWSHO and the SHOW HIO today expressed concerns that the USDA is not implementing the scar rule correctly and as a result sound and HPA compliant horses are unjustly being turned away from horse shows.

“In my opinion, the USDA is wrongly disqualifying sound horses from the Celebration,” said Jane Lynch Crain, TWSHO spokesman. “It is unfair to the trainers, riders and owners who love their horses and are doing everything possible to prove the soundness of their horses only to be turned away for an unjustified ruling.”

According to the HPA regulations, in order for a scar rule violation to be issued, there has to be bilateral evidence of abuse indicative of soring, in other words a scar on both feet.  USDA inspectors are improperly identifying natural marks such as wrinkles, field injuries, tissue changes caused by the motion of a walking horse’s gait, the normal aging process, and conformation of the lower limbs as violations that are exempted from the HPA and do not mean a horse has been abused.

At this year’s Celebration, the number of USDA violations that are scar rule disqualifications have significantly increased in comparison to last year’s Celebration. In the first six days, USDA inspectors have issued over five times the number of scar rule violations that they issued last year over the entire 11-day show.  Additionally, a local horse passed USDA inspection twice on Thursday and was found to be free of scars. On Friday, the same horse was disqualified under the scar rule, even though it is medically impossible to develop a scar on both feet within 24 hours. When the owner questioned the USDA’s lead inspector at the event he said he could not explain the ruling.

Some of the horses who were disqualified by the USDA at Celebration for the scar rule were inspected by SHOW HIO inspectors and Dr. Scott Hopper a renowned equine veterinarian from Rood & Riddle a premier equine hospital in Lexington, Kentucky. Both the SHOW HIO inspectors and Dr. Hopper found the horses to be sound and in compliance with the HPA.

This scar rule has been marred by a lack of consistency in determining sound horses and is why industry reformers are seeking to move to science based testing as the technology becomes available. There is a well known affidavit signed by the former President of the Mississippi Walking Horse Association that details the discrepancies between USDA inspectors in applying the rule at a scar clinic she attended. At the clinic two USDA inspectors failed to render the same opinion on a scar rule 26% of the time. In 2010 horses were allowed to be disqualified at one inspection and be re-inspected for a later show at the same event. The rules were changed in 2010 to disqualify the horse from the entire event if found in violation because there had been so many discrepancies among USDA inspectors over the scar rule. A horse would fail one inspection and be disqualified, then later he would be inspected for a different class and pass. On August 12, 2012 in Wartrace, TN a flag horse passed USDA inspection and several

hours later the same USDA inspector found the same flag horse in violation of the scar rule – a medically impossible scenario.

Under the HPA Regulations the controversial and highly subjective scar rule is defined as follows;

Sec. 11.3 Scar rule.

The scar rule applies to all horses born on or after October 1, 1975. Horses subject to this rule that do not meet the following scar rule criteria shall be considered to be ``sore'' and are subject to all prohibitions of section 5 of the Act. The scar rule criteria are as follows:

(a) The anterior and anterior-lateral surfaces of the fore pasterns (extensor surface) must be free of bilateral granulomas,\5\ other bilateral pathological evidence of inflammation, and, other bilateral evidence of abuse indicative of soring including, but not limited to, excessive loss of hair.
(b) The posterior surfaces of the pasterns (flexor surface), including the sulcus or ``pocket'' may show bilateral areas of uniformly thickened epithelial tissue if such areas are free of proliferating granuloma tissue, irritation, moisture, edema, or other evidence of inflammation.

More Stories

  • Equine Obituary - Gen’s Armed & Dangerous

    The Report has recently learned of the passing of Gen’s Armed and Dangerous. The beautiful stallion was the 1994 Tennessee Walking Horse World Grand Champion. Read More
  • Ohio Valley adds class

    Ohio Valley Walking Horse Association show, scheduled for June 23 in Stanford, Kentucky, has added a 4 and Under Trail Pleasure to their show.  Read More
  • Walking For Hope Show updates

    The Walking For Hope show, scheduled for June 16, has selected Chris Zahnd to judge this year’s event. Originally scheduled to start at 4:00, the show will start at 5:00 pm. Read More
  • WHOA Versatility revises class schedule

    The Walking Horse Owners Association has added 5 classes to its June 16 show scheduled at Tennessee Tech, Hyder-Burk Facility in Cookeville, TN. The show starts at 10 am and is a casual dress show (boots, long pants, shirts with a collar) and "Youth 11 and Under" are required to wear a safety helmet. Read More
  • Putnam Co. Fair selects judge

    The Putnam County Fair and Upper Cumberland Walking Horse Association are pleased to announce that Newton Parks of Murfreesboro, Tennessee will judge this year’s event... Read More
  • Wartrace selects judge

    The 112th Anniversary Wartrace Horse Show has selected John Fikes of Hamilton, Alabama to judge this year's event and has released their class schedule... Read More
  • Walking For The Children selects judge

    The Walking For The Children Show, scheduled for July 26, has selected Aaron Self of Murfreesboro, Tennessee to mark the cards for this year's event. Read More
  • WHAA Summer Classic selects Cotten

    The WHAA Summer Classic, scheduled for June 16, has selected Joe Cotten to mark the cards for this years event... Read More
  • Obituary - Bill Carmichael

    Walking horse trainer, William D. "Bill" Carmichael, 59, passed away suddenly on Wednesday morning. He was born on October 13, 1958 to Audria Carmichael and the late William Carmichael. He married his adoring wife Cindy Conyers Carmichael and together they had two wonderful children... Read More
  • BPWHA Broadhead show rescheduled

    The Bluegrass Pleasure & Walking Horse Show, originally scheduled for May 19, has been rescheduled for October 14 at 1:00 pm.  Read More